Work

Editorial

Year: 2007
Type: editorial
Abstract: We start this issue with a paper that has already caused some controversy. Karlheinz Kautz, Sabine Madsen and Jacob Nørbjerg compare ‘traditional’ and present day ‘Web-based’ information systems development (ISD) and suggest that the differences can be explained as an accentuated evolution of well-known challenges which remain persistent. The claim in the literature that modern Web-based information systems (IS) demand new development paradigms because Web development is fundamentally different is examined critically. Two representative case examples that contrast Web-based and traditional practices are analysed and compared to show that they have more in common than might be expected. A particularly interesting feature of the paper is that the authors adopt a hermeneutic approach to understanding contradictions in the ISD literature. In this process they analyse a previous paper, Baskerville & Pries-Heje (2004), published in the ISJ. However, they derive different conclusions than those of the original authors. The associate editor of the paper, Duane Truex, thought it appropriate to ask Richard Baskerville and Jan Pries-Heje to comment on it. They, along with Balasubramaniam Ramesh, have provided a thoughtful response that also recognizes the significance of the agile movement in software development as potentially the major change, rather than merely one branch of development for Web applications. Following tradition, we allowed the original authors a chance to respond again. Whatever ‘side’ you decide to take, we are grateful to all these authors for allowing us to be a party to their written academic debate. We would like to see more opportunities for such debate in the ISJ. Following on from this study looking at Web development, we have two papers examining different aspects of Web-based learning. The first of Simon Chan and Eric Ngai presents a qualitative study on how 10 organizations adopted Web-based training (WBT). The cases reflect the experience and concerns of human resource management practitioners who have struggled with their decision to adopt WBT. The authors conclude that there are three key factors associated with the adoption of WBT: the perceived benefits of WBT, organization readiness, and external pressure, and the many quotations used in the paper from interviewees lend weight to the inferences drawn. The paper of Chao-Min Chiu, Chao-Sheng Chiu and Hae-Ching Chang links well with the previous paper as it looks specifically at user satisfaction and other factors that eventually increase users' intentions to continue using Web-based learning services. The issue of ‘fairness’ is particularly interesting, and this provides a useful perspective in understanding technology adoption. The study suggests that information quality, system quality, system use, distributive fairness and interactional fairness exhibit significant positive effects on satisfaction, and procedural fairness and satisfaction play significant roles in shaping learners' intention to continue using Web-based learning. Readers might be surprised that the editors have accepted a paper based on research on students, but of course in this case (unlike many others), the students are not surrogates for others but are indeed Web-based learners themselves. As for the authors of our first paper, Helen Richardson and Bruce Robinson were also motivated by a paper in the ISJ. Because of the absence of the critical paradigm in Chen & Hirschheim's (2004) historical review of IS research papers published between 1991and 2001, the authors conducted an analysis of IS publications specifically searching for papers that adopted a critical perspective. By adding critical research to the analysis, the paper presents an important contribution to understanding the IS research landscape. It fills the gap in the IS literature that has mostly ignored the development of the critical approach in the field. The paper questions some assumptions and draws attention to misconceptions in critical IS research and thus contributes to understanding its nature and importance. This paper not only adds to Chen and Hirschheim, but also to an earlier paper on critical research by Kathy McGrath (2005).
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4241690711
Cites: 3
Cited by: 3
Related to: 9