Work

Editorial

Year: 2018
Type: editorial
Abstract: Welcome to the second issue of the European Journal of Archaeology (EJA) for 2018.Here, we present five new articles (ranging from ancient DNA studies to chronological issues to material culture studies), followed by nine book reviews.Below, we summarize and comment on these contributions.Martin Furholt reviews the impact of recent human aDNA studies on our understanding of third millennium BC Europe.He points out that new genetic data are often interpreted in a manner that recalls aspects of traditional culture-historical archaeology, including questionable claims of large and homogeneous archaeological culture groups (e.g.Bell Beakers, Corded Ware and Yamnaya) and 'massive migrations'.Furholt, instead, calls for more subtle interpretations, informed by social theories of human mobility and migration.Comments on his article are provided by aDNA specialists Wolfgang Haak and Eva Fernández-Domínguez and by European prehistorians Daniela Hofmann and Marc Vander Linden.Haak's response highlights his primarily biologically-and statistically-informed perspective on gene flow and genetic ancestry, whereas the three other commentators generally welcome Furholt's critique.Some of the lessons to be learnt from this exercise are: that the study of aDNA continues to be a fastmoving field; that we must all acknowledge the limitations of archaeogenetic data; and that constructive dialogue between archaeological theorists and geneticists, which brings together the social as well as the biological dimensions of population history, dramatically enhances our capacity to formulate and test more sophisticated hypotheses.Gonzalo Aranda Jiménez and colleagues present the results of their radiocarbon dating and Bayesian modelling programme, designed to shed light on the origins and development of the megalithic cemetery of El Barranquete in south-eastern Spain.Their dataset comprises 45 dated samples, the majority of human bone, from four tombs.These data suggest that the cemetery was used over an unexpectedly long period of time, between the late fourth millennium cal BC and the last centuries of the second millennium cal BC.They propose that megalithic mortuary practices continued, first, from the Copper Age into the Early Bronze Age (arguably as part of a social strategy involving adherence to, by then, very old mortuary practices and resistance to social differentiation), and then, after a short hiatus around 1500 cal BC coinciding with the disappearance of the Argaric culture, on into the Late Bronze Age.The data also reveal that each tomb had a complex and distinctive biography.It will be interesting to see how these results compare to those emerging from the megalithic site of Valencina de la Concepción and other Iberian funerary complexes.In a comparable study, Nick Card and colleagues provide two complementary chronological models for the development of the special Late Neolithic site at Ness of Brodgar in the Orkney Islands off the north-east coast of Scotland.Here, ongoing excavations have revealed a complex sequence of monumental buildings within a massive walled
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4245543349
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10