Work

Editorial

Year: 1998
Type: editorial
Abstract: Many of the articles included in this issue prompt us to ask some uncomfortable questions about what is worthwhile in musical education (and what is not); about whether innovations are really helpful or simply allow us to duck more central issues; and about the piecemeal nature of curriculum development in music, despite the corset of the National Curriculum.These are not new questions, as Gordon Cox's historical research reveals so vividly.He traces the birth and demise of Musical Education of the Under-Twelves (MEUT), a movement that lasted from 1949 until 1983.Many of the most distinguished British musical educators of that era threw their energies and influence behind attempts to revitalise music in schools, only to see their idealism dissipated in wrangling and spurned by teachers who were reluctant to embrace change.The ideas and practices encouraged by MEUT were remarkably wide-ranging: percussion band; work modelled on the principles of Orff and Kodaly; composition; music and movement; focused listening (often connected to broadcasts); and musical notation.Although this is a familiar menu, notable new arrivals in music classrooms occupy the attention of other contributors to this issue of the BJME.Among the innovations are the increased use of information technology; a more intense study of non-European music; an acceptance that a wider variety of idioms (popular music in particular) is worthy of pupils' attention; and the involvement of professional musicians in auricular music.I am not sure whether these innovations should be regarded as the new fruit of a healthy plant or as attempts to 'rescue' music as a curriculum subject.Among our contributors, Malcolm Ross may be in an especially strong position to offer an informed opinion, since his recent research replicates work carried out in the 1970s when, with Robert Witkin, he confirmed that music was considered the least popular of school subjects by the large number of pupils interviewed.His more recent research reinforces this gloomy picture in most respects, but that is not the main thrust of his article.He compares some of the uplifting musical experiences he encountered at the Dartington International Summer School in 1998 with the more baleful evidence from schools.He declares, 'Frankly, if music education -as instruction and assessment -cannot be reformed it should be allowed to die'.But who is going to decide what the reforms might be, and who will do the reforming?If anything, the trend seems to flow the opposite way.The National Curriculum could well be regarded as 'a reform', but voices are being raised in protest at the prescriptive and even proscriptive nature of the requirements of the National Curriculum, especially in its most recent revision.We are not comfortable with 'reforms' imposed upon us, yet the meagre allowance of time for music at all key stages, and the obligation to cover the statutory programmes of study at Key Stage 3, inhibit innovation.In some schools, music (among other subjects) may be heading for
Language: English
Subfield: Music
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4245715620
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10