Work

A reply

Year: 2004
Type: article
Abstract: We are thankful for the occasion to respond to some thoughtful remarks by our colleague Dr Meek. Indeed, the parturients were not in labour during the antepartum spirometry. Performing spirometry during active labour as suggested by Dr Meek would not have produced valid and reproducible results since spirometry depends on good cooperation and performance at best effort. It has been shown that pain reduces the level of maximum respiratory effort, therefore spirometry performed during painful uterine contractions would have yielded unreliable and probably incorrect tracings that would not have been representative for changes related to the pregnant state per se. A spirometric evaluation between contractions would also have been of questionable value since even though parturients are known to be pain-free between the contractions [1], exhaustion resulting from painful labour would have had an impact on spirometry performed during active labour. In addition, it seems rather inappropriate to ask parturients to perform spirometry at a time when they need to recover and likely are tense in expectation of the next contraction. All these factors are likely to interfere with parturient's volition and spirometry. Therefore measuring spirometry directly prior to epidural analgesia would not have provided us with valid information. As stated in the Results section, the median (IQR [range]) time between the antepartum assessment (first spirometry) and effective epidural analgesia (second spirometry) was 11 (8–18[5–51]) h and between the start of active labour and effective epidural analgesia (second spirometry) 2.0 (1.5–3.0[0.5–8.0]) h. Of course, the process of labour might account for some of the differences in our spirometric results, e.g. the descent of the foetus might improve respiratory function. This change, however, is counterbalanced by the impact of increasing pain intensity during the progression of labour and exhaustion, both of which are likely to worsen respiratory function. The goal of our study was to answer the question as to whether epidural analgesia worsens or improves spirometric parameters during labour and we therefore focussed on a particular period of early labour. The key finding was that epidural analgesia for labour pain does not worsen respiratory function in spite of its effects on muscular function but rather tends to improve spirometric parameters.
Source: Anaesthesia
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4245902215
FWCI:
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10