Year: 2013
Type: letter
Abstract: We thank Dr Xue and colleagues for pointing out the discrepancies between Table 1 and the summary of our paper 1. The numbers were erroneously calculated when the data format was changed from mean/SD to median/range. The corrected data are now published in a Corrigendum 2. Despite this error, we wish to emphasise that the conclusion of our study remains unchanged. We also apologise for this mistake. Xue et al. suggests that lack of experience accounted for the lower success rate and longer time to tracheal intubation using the InnoScope compared with the Macintosh laryngoscope in our difficult airway scenario. We attempted to minimise this bias by recruiting anaesthetists without prior experience with the SimMan simulator. We allowed participants to practise intubation in the ‘normal airway’ manikin only, so that their experience of handling a 'difficult airway' in the manikin would be broadly equivalent. Therefore, familiarity with the Macintosh laryngoscope alone is unlikely to explain the inferior performance with the InnoScope in the difficult airway. Based on the comparable success rate and time to successful intubation between the two devices in ‘normal airway’ scenarios, we believe the participants were largely proficient with both devices in the manikin. We agree with Xue et al. that better training with the InnoScope may improve the success rate for intubation. However, the minimum practice for any airway device before one is considered a proficient user is currently undefined. Given that most anaesthetists are primarily trained using a Macintosh laryngoscope, it may be impossible to avoid differing levels of experience when comparing new airway devices with the classic Macintosh laryngoscope. We allowed participants to bend the optical stylet before each attempt at intubation. Unfortunately, we did not measure the curvature and cannot comment on the relationship between angulation of the stylet and successful intubation. Following unsuccessful attempts with the InnoScope, participants generally readjusted the distal curvature to accommodate for the unexpected anatomical variation. Other manoeuvres included repositioning of the head and external laryngeal pressure. We believe that further modification of the InnoScope to allow real-time adjustment of distal angulation may improve its success rate.
Source: Anaesthesia
DOI: 10.1111/anae.12247
Institutions: Tuen Mun Hospital, Prince of Wales Hospital
Language: English
Subfield: Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4246843366
