Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: Thank you to Dr Palmer for his interest in my paper. I agree with his analogy that in terms of safety, anaesthesia is like a relatively unprotected cyclist compared with the modern car of the nuclear power industry, which is protected by many safety systems. However, Dr Palmer's suggestion of further study into why some people respond better in crises than others comprises a ’person centred’ approach to safety improvement – and is likely to be ineffective in achieving long-term safety gains unless translated into the redesign of at least the procedures, and preferably the physical systems, used in anaesthesia. Teaching clinicians better coping strategies and re-designing protocols can improve safety, but even this qualifies only as a relatively weak Phase 2 safety approach [1]. Redesigning the physical systems used in anaesthesia physically to prevent or discourage incorrect alternatives is a more powerful safety approach (a Phase 4 strategy) as it eliminates many of the vagaries that are a concomitant of all human performance. Such a ‘systems approach’ is the opposite of the person approach and this change in perspective seems to be a long time in coming in anaesthesia. To ensure such system redesign is appropriate and targets problem areas, it should be based on good quality, anonymous incident data, which is the best sustainable source of information about actual system performance. Critically, effective system redesign requires the focus of safety initiatives to be widened from the individual clinician to the larger technological system within which the clinician acts – and the persistence of the person approach in medicine frequently prevents this. Until such a wider focus is adopted, most faults embedded throughout medical systems will remain out of sight and unresolved. The systems approach does not detract from the importance of the anaesthetist's clinical expertise, nor should it lead to inappropriate system redesign which hampers the anaesthetist. Good system redesign should provide a more robustly error-tolerant working environment, while simultaneously increasing safety and facilitating performance.
Source: Anaesthesia
Author: C. S. Webster
Institution: University of Auckland
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4247120319
