Year: 2020
Type: editorial
Abstract: Evaluation is often described these days as 'theory driven' or at least 'theory informed'.That is certainly instantiated in the first four articles in this issue.Very different theories but very potently deployed.The next four articles follow a more analytical and methodological tradition.Øyunn Høydal asks us to reconsider the often-assumed divide between on one hand knowledge producers such as evaluators and researchers, and on the other, those who use this knowledge in the policy community.Instead of the 'two communities' assumption, Høydal argues that 'policy is part of knowledge production in the same way as knowledge production is part of policy'.This 'coproduction' framing builds on Peter Dahler-Larsen's understanding of influence at different 'moments' in an evaluation process -from initiation through to reporting of results.Norwegian civil servants in six public agencies were surveyed and interviews were also conducted.The author's findings raise interesting questions about knowledge brokering.This is often thought of as an independent, external and mediating role.Øyunn Høydal highlights how this role is also fulfilled by civil servants who mediate between political demands for answers and validation, and what can legitimately be said on the basis of evaluation studies.As so often in evaluation, it is the taken for granted and quotidian that challenges us most.Ghislain Arbour takes on one such: the notion of 'evaluation frameworks'.The author sets out to bring order into the diverse and often confusing picture of how frameworks are understood.Rather than to aim for a common understanding, Arbour instead provides a model that 'acknowledges a variety of types of framework and offers a conceptual rationale for their inclusion'.According to Arbour, this 'allows frameworks to be differentiated from non-frameworks, allows for identification of frameworks [ . . .] and allows users to efficiently harness the potential of different framework types'.Arbour's model encompasses theories, concepts and intellectual insights; a normative or value element; the 'object of evaluation' which can encompass both 'interventions' and those who evaluate or manage evaluation process; as well as institutional including regulatory and accountability aspects.The authors' discussion of how this model can be applied to a host of different frameworks is thought provoking: as a good model should be!Jone Martínez-Palacios and Igor Ahedo apply 'critical deliberative theory' to the evolving notions of gender, encompassing gender identities and self-expression, as well as diverse sexual orientations.For the authors, this is set against a 'common goal' of democratisation.Evaluation from a 'Gender+ Perspective' sets out to 'compare the learnings of the critique of deliberative democracy and the feminist view of evaluation'.This builds substantially on Maria Bustelo's conceptualisation of Evaluation from a Gender+ Perspective (EG+P) 'as substantially political and incorporating an inclusive perspective that includes social justice'.966442E VI0010.
Source: Evaluation
Author: Elliot Stern
Language: Spanish
Subfield: Public Administration
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4247941932
