Year: 2010
Type: article
Abstract: classification methods for patients with lumbar impair-ments using the McKenzie syndromes, pain pattern, manipulation and stabilization clinical prediction rules’ We would like to thank Dr Fritz for her articulate and insightful commentary, which has raised several important issues concerning the conceptualization of classification systems appropriate for routine clinical practice. There are several points by Dr Fritz, which we believe require additional comment. Before we address additional comments, we need to remember that our paper was not designed to compare the overall Mechanical Diagnosis and Therapy (MDT)1 and Treatment-Based Classification (TBC)2 para-digms. We simply analyzed prevalence rates of core levels of MDT system for our entire sample and for patients positive for two clinical prediction rules (CPRs).3,4 There were two important findings. First, the CPRs were applicable to a limited number of patients in routine clinical practice. Second, of those who were positive for the CPRs, a majority had centralizing symptoms, which implies that they may be managed successfully using prescriptive strategies described in the MDT philosophy. We agree with Dr Fritz that evaluating the prevalence rates between different classification systems must consider the level of classification being compared (i.e. overall paradigm or system, individual category or subgroup, or specific criterion). However, it is equally important to consider the patient case-mix and practice setting in order to appreciate the potential clinical implications for the comparative prevalence rate data reported in different studies. For example, we believe that the high prevalence rates reported by Dr Fritz, ranging between 23–45 % for manipulation and 24–41 % for stabilization CPRs,5–7 can be primarily explained by differences in patient case-mix and practice setting rather than differences between comparing prevalence rates for an individual
Authors: Mark W. Werneke, Dennis L. Hart
Institution: CentraState Healthcare Foundation
Language: English
Field: Health Professions
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4249732459
