Work

Editorial

Year: 2017
Type: editorial
Abstract: This issue starts with a paper on homœopathy, a subject which raises many a hackle, including among those we asked to referee the paper.Experts in homœopathy were least supportive in that they seemed to be unfamiliar with the process of peer review and were unwilling to say anything at all about the paper.Referees from the science policy community were actively opposed to anything to do with homœopathy and reluctant to lend it respectability by refereeing a paper even mentioning the subject.The attitude of experts in the boundary work community was quite different; from their perspective, homœopathy provided an excellent example of the techniques of marginalisation.Their reports on the paper were enthusiastic.There would seem to be a lesson for editors here: particularly in contentious areas, the perspective of referees is likely to colour the referee's report.Joanne Greenwood, from the University of Wollongong, has not, of course, written a paper on homœopathy.Rather, she draws upon the case of homœopathy for evidence of marginalisation by the National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC), the body which distributes research funding on behalf of the Australian government.She examines and classifies the various techniques usedperhaps unconsciouslyby the NHMRC to marginalise homœopathy and to maintain the dominance of conventional medicine.A team from a number of Dutch research institutions is also critical of the means by which dominant technology and institutions act as constraints on innovation.
Source: Prometheus
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W4250690912
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10