Work

Editorials

Year: 1973
Type: editorial
Abstract: Medical EducationVolume 7, Issue 3 p. 136-145 Free Access Editorials First published: September 1973 https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2923.1973.tb01868.xAboutSectionsPDF ToolsRequest permissionExport citationAdd to favoritesTrack citation ShareShare Give accessShare full text accessShare full-text accessPlease review our Terms and Conditions of Use and check box below to share full-text version of article.I have read and accept the Wiley Online Library Terms and Conditions of UseShareable LinkUse the link below to share a full-text version of this article with your friends and colleagues. Learn more.Copy URL Share a linkShare onFacebookTwitterLinkedInRedditWechat 1. The standard of British medical education Few, if any, of the many reports on Medicine and the Health Services that have emerged in recent times are likely to be of greater importance for the quality of British medical education and medical care than that which will eventually come from the Government-appointed Committee of Enquiry into the Regulation of the Medical Profession. The Committee, under the chairmanship of Dr A. W. Merrison, Vice-Chancellor of the University of Bristol, will in effect be considering how in future those functions will be fulfilled which are now the responsibility of the General Medical Council. They are educational and disciplinary, but it is only with the first that we are concerned here. Since 1858 the General Medical Council has been statutorily responsible to the Privy Council, not to the Government of the day, for keeping a register of doctors licensed to practise, and for ensuring that none is placed on the register who has not received an adequate minimum preparation, in Britain or elsewhere. The register is published and with that publication the educational function of the Council in regard to the individual has ended. Whatever status or privileges have been conferred on the registered doctor, or whatever constraints have been imposed on him, have come not from the Council but from the public or employers or by statute, regulation, and Common Law. Medical education produces doctors for the future. It has always been a lengthy process. Even within its shortest duration, say four years, after long, specially orientated secondary schooling, much can now change with medicine and medical care. Medical education, therefore, now more than ever before, must have its sights on the future and must use present facilities as best it can in the service of its long-term goals. Not infrequently its requirements may conflict with what are seen to be the current needs of medical care, or thought to be the current desires of the medical profession. It is seldom easy for anyone, individuals, organizations, or governments (especially those dependent on the votes of the public), to curtail resources that could be made available for the care of the sick today, in order to provide medical education with the support which, according to the relatively few who are engaged in it, is necessary to ensure a satisfactory quantity and quality of doctors tomorrow. It is particularly difficult now that medicine has changed so much that an adequate preparation for it can no longer be acquired relatively cheaply by a simple system of apprenticeship. Yet it is imperative that neither the provision of facilities for medical education, nor the approval of courses, nor the registration of doctors should be exposed to the dictates of expediency or established interests. It is, therefore, essential that the body statutorily responsible for the standard of medical education be entirely independent of the government health department and of the medical profession, though it is obviously appropriate and advantageous for it to include representation of both. The General Medical Council has always been in exactly that situation and has been in a position to keep the public interest as its primary concern, and not the benefit of the medical profession or the immediate needs of health services in Britain. Its composition has included, in addition to representatives of the bodies engaged in medical education, representatives of the profession not so engaged, of the government service and of the public - the latter two groups of representatives being nominated by the Crown. It is no wonder, therefore, that, whenever international committees or expert working groups have studied the mechanisms by which the standard of medical education can be controlled, and medical education related to the needs of medical care, the British system has been regarded with almost universal envy. The establishment of a Committee of Enquiry into it can, in consequence, occasion some surprise. Those who have followed correspondence in British medical journals in the last year or so might imagine that the issue now being raised was a demand by the profession to take and keep control of medical education in its own interests. Such claims have recently been published and some authors have even apparently appreciated that were their demands to be met, medicine would cease to be a profession. However, the evidence of the British Medical Association to the Merrison Committee (published in the Supplement to the British Medical Journal, 2, 159–175, on 30 June 1973) shows that the profession in general has a more thoughtful and responsibly-minded attitude to the matter. It also reveals, as does the evidence of the General Medical Council to Merrison published in the same issue (the recommendations of which follow this Editorial), the reasons why changes in the control of the standard of medical education must be made. Foremost among these reasons is the fact that neither the General Medical Council nor any other body has statutory responsibility for the standard of postgraduate medical education. Secondly, the Council is bound by the Medical Act of 1886, which requires that all doctors in order to become eligible for registration have passed a qualifying examination in medicine, surgery, and midwifery. The Act provides that ‘the standard of proficiency required from candidates … shall be such as sufficiently to guarantee the possession of the knowledge and skill requisite for the efficient practise of medicine, surgery and midwifery’. To quote from the evidence of the Council: ‘These provisions were subsequently re-enacted in section 10 of the consolidating Medical Act of 1956, and are still the law of the land. But they no longer accord with the facts of contemporary medical practice, and with the passage of time they have become an obstacle to the re-formulation of the undergraduate medical curriculum in the light of contemporary needs. Nowadays it is unrealistic to suppose that any medical student, at the termination of the undergraduate curriculum, can possess the knowledge and skill requisite for the efficient practise of medicine, surgery and midwifery. It is only after a considerable period of postgraduate training and experience that doctors are regarded as competent to practise without supervision surgery, midwifery or one of the other branches of medicine (in its widest sense), and so to have achieved “recognized competence to exercise independent clinical judgement in a specialty”in the sense in which this term was used in paragraph 185 of the Report of the Royal Commission on Medical Education (The Todd Report, Cmnd 3569).’ In simple terms it is no longer possible for a medical school to turn schoolboys, or even college graduates in other subjects, into fully prepared doctors. A further period of training is essential which, for numerous reasons (educational, financial, and other), must be in a participatory situation incompatible with the trainee remaining a student. There has to be undergraduate education and postgraduate training. This is what the adaptation of medical education to contemporary medicine is all about. It is the all-important fundamental issue. By comparison curriculum reformation, the application of educational technology, teaching teachers how to teach, are all secondary. The extent to which they can lead to improvement is determined by whether or not a two-stage preparation for medicine is provided. Many countries have long since recognized and met the need for a two-stage medical preparation. Most young doctors have recognized the need also and have sought postgraduate training wherever they can find it, many having to migrate to do so and others having to make sacrifices of other kinds, such as those in Britain who forgo the home comforts and the rich financial rewards of an early untrained entry into general practice. But postgraduate training in Britain, though much improved in recent years by more thoughtful organization, remains a part of medical education for the standard of which no body is charged with statutory responsibility. Yet it is the part on which public safety now mainly depends, for during it the individual acquires the knowledge and skill relevant to the current practice of a given branch of medicine. In 1968, the Royal Commission on Medical Education recommended a second, vocational, register to inform the public as to which doctors had completed training for the independent practice of general or specialist medicine. It also recommended that the General Medical Council should keep this register and take responsibility for the standard of postgraduate training. These were the only two recommendations requiring parliamentary legislation. The following year the Government announced its preparedness to accept these recommendations but professional sources requested time to consider. Now in 1973 both the General Medical Council and the British Medical Association have recorded in their evidence to the Merrison Committee their view that the regulatory body of the future must relate to both postgraduate and undergraduate medical education in a manner similar to that in which the General Medical Council has related to undergraduate medical education in the past. It is fervently to be hoped that the Merrison Committee will recommend the same, for when at long last such a recommendation is implemented Britain will not only have taken the vital step which will allow her own medical education to be adapted to modern times but she will also have given a much needed lead to those many countries which share a common heritage in the training of doctors. Basic medical education Freed from the now totally out-of-date constraints of the 1886 Act it will be possible for the medical schools to design, and the regulatory body to approve, curricula which are flexible, capable of being educationally effective and (once postgraduate training before independent practice is assured) probably shorter in duration. The quality of education, however, will then depend less on the curriculum than on the degree to which the schools (originally built and equipped to provide vocational training) possess the staff, space and funds that are needed. The maintenance of the standard of basic medical education will therefore depend very largely on approval of the schools, rather than the courses. The regulatory body must be in a position to inspect schools and must also develop and apply methods of assessing schools that go far beyond the process of recurrent visitation, and which include assessment of the systems of examination. The preregistration period will remain a most important part of basic medical education. It is appropriate that the onus of recommending approval of posts should rest with the medical schools but their continuing review of posts would be conducted more assiduously if they themselves were subject to more rigorous recurrent appraisal by the regulatory body. The latter should, in addition, be able itself to review individual posts when necessary and thus on occasion to withhold approval even if recommended. Use should also be made of the system of publishing recommendations, which has proved a valuable means of indicating desired standards to the medical schools. Recommendations on the purpose and methods of preregistration training, addressed to the National Health Service personnel who provide the bulk of the training, are long overdue. The profession has always shown willingness, in and out of medical schools, to accept training of the young as a privilege which brings its own reward, but, in the absence of any authoritative information, consultants cannot be expected to know the objectives of any particular phase of the continuum of preparation. Postgraduate training As the prime purpose of postgraduate training is the acquisition of competence in the current practice of a given branch of medicine it is important that its content be prescribed to ensure coverage of the knowledge and skill relevant to that branch. Maintenance of standards in postgraduate training, therefore, will depend as much upon approval of the courses as of the places of training. A minimum core content must be laid down together with a minimum training period which in effect will indicate the shortest possible sequence of posts considered necessary. There need be no requirement that any individual has to proceed by this shortest route but it is clearly necessary that those appointments deemed essential should be held in approved posts. Until recently there was no organization for the conduct and delivery of postgraduate training. There has now been developed, however, an organization which at local, regional, and national (the Councils for Postgraduate Medical Education) levels includes the three essential elements: the Universities, the Royal Colleges and other professional associations, and the Department of Health. It is capable of providing for each major branch of medicine a ‘licensing body’ which could be recognized by the regulatory body and could act towards it in the postgraduate field in the same way as medical schools for the undergraduate. Each ‘licensing body’ should be responsible to the regulatory body for ensuring that an individual's training has met the minimal course requirements and that the required minimal time has been spent in approved posts. ‘Licensing bodies’ should be responsible for regular reviewing of posts and for recommending to the regulatory body those that should be approved. As with preregistration posts the regulatory body should be empowered itself to inspect individual posts when necessary. It should be possible in the postgraduate field for training to be closely related to the needs of medical care, with adjustments being made between the two separately in relation to each branch whenever necessary. In this way both the public interest and public safety will be served, while it will be possible also to ensure the maintenance of standards in basic medical education without limiting that academic freedom for the pursuit of educational excellence which is the traditional contribution of universities to the common good. Continuing education As medical knowledge and its application to practice both continue to change rapidly, the standard of medical care must in future be dependent to a considerable degree on the continuing education undertaken by doctors from the time they complete their training onwards throughout their working lives. Where, as in Britain, the pattern of medical education includes a university course intended to equip the future doctor with the ability to learn for himself and to evaluate new knowledge, together with a lasting desire to learn, the success of continuing education will be closely related to the success of the undergraduate course. Nonetheless it can be powerfully affected by the extent to which facilities, including time, are made available and it is important, therefore, that responsibility for ensuring the standard of continuing education should be vested in the independent regulatory body. The fulfilment of this responsibility may well prove one of its most onerous tasks, for continuing education poses several problems. These include not only what education should be offered, how, where and when, but also the problem of discovering whether, after a considerable commitment of public funds and professional energy in providing courses, substantial changes do actually occur in the practising habits of those doctors who attended. Registration Satisfactory completion of the undergraduate course should continue to be signified by probationary-registration, and satisfactory completion of the preregistration period by first registration. Satisfactory completion of postgraduate training for a given branch of medicine should be signified by registration in that branch. The registration of doctors who have completed all, or more commonly part of their preparation overseas, is complicated by the fact that two particularly important criteria are clinical competence and linguistic ability. At the present time neither of these can be accurately assessed by examinations taken in the doctor's own country. The American ECFMG examination which is taken in many countries, assesses clinical competence only to a limited extent and while testing comprehension of written English does not attempt to test the candidate's ability to speak English. It is not practicable for a British regulatory body so accurately to assess every medical school overseas or every internship as to be able to grant or refuse to grant a probationary or first registration on the grounds of basic medical education received outside Britain. It is no easier to assess postgraduate training overseas. The interests of both British patients and those of immigrant doctors will best be served if the majority of doctors who come to this country are assessed by a clinical attachment and are rated in regard to their clinical competence and linguistic ability. They may be rated as ready for independent clinical responsibility in general practice or a specialty and granted the appropriate registration. They may be rated as unready for first registration (in which case further education in this country cannot be guaranteed) or most commonly will be rated as eligible for first registration and ready for further training at the level of House Officer, Registrar, Senior Registrar, or equivalent grades in university posts. The existing clinical attachment scheme is intended for exactly this purpose, but it is far from efficient. It will remain so until the assessors are more clearly informed as to their function and the methods to be used; are themselves approved by the regulatory body on the recommendation of an appropriate organization, and are provided with all that is necessary, including time, for their task. It is a task of great importance not only to this country but to many others which would benefit more than they now do if their medical graduates obtained more effective postgraduate training more quickly as a result of better grading at the outset. The National Health Service makes it possible to operate an efficient clinical attachment scheme and the additional cost of operating it efficiently would be more than justified by the benefits from overseas should be granted first or registration without assessment as an of the regulatory body the of its functions in regard to medical education the regulatory body must of the engaged in medical education, of the profession outside those organizations, of the of the of Health. It would be if those most engaged in the conduct of medical education made the body responsible for and its It would be if the body not include representation of those with most experience in this of every medical school and other educational organization is A should be however, between by educational organizations, and by the regulatory body itself for of their experience of medical education. The representatives of the engaged in medical education should be by those and should include a given from the medical schools in always the University of a from the medical schools in one from the National of Medicine and from and a given from the Royal Colleges and similar professional engaged in postgraduate medical education. In addition the regulatory body itself should a of engaged in medical education so as to ensure the of further in the subject and a between its many The representatives of the profession outside the engaged in medical education should no or in any of those and should include both young and more and both and They should be by the profession. of the public should be nominated by the on the of the Privy Council and no purpose would be served by these being in a from each of the of Health should be nominated by those In any educational established by the regulatory body those engaged in medical education should not less than of the As there is a of between the and the of it is that the same standards should or not this should be achieved by a regulatory body can be only by between the two a body be representation of the of should be achieved by a in each of the four groups of which the body should be and means have been in the by approval of the places of education or training, by approval of courses, by and by registration. The same methods used should be adequate in but the placed upon must as between basic medical education, postgraduate training, and continuing education. They should be as the General Medical Council not to ensure minimum satisfactory standards but also to the But the methods of control and efficiently will only ensure that medical education is at the to the standard the regulatory body is the is that that is made on the of information, and not on The General Medical Council out that it has not been empowered to information, by and other on all relevant to the education and training of a In future the regulatory body must be able to all the it but the of will not by itself The of on medical education is no easy task and much has to be to develop better Yet much could be achieved by the application of existing The recurrent appraisal to which American medical schools are is far more than any of the relatively that have been made to schools in Britain. by its of medical and has shown other by which medical education can be It should be possible to learn the at which graduates knowledge and skill to allow a on the of postgraduate training for a given branch of medicine to be by more than at The of the necessary must be for and while it is that the cost of Medical should on the registered it is neither nor that the cost of the standards of medical education should be by the profession It should be met by the but not the of Health or the Department of Education and The regulatory educational functions should be from the It will then need to use those funds for its own and also to for made by Those in in medical education are not to The Royal Commission on Medical Education its with the that its own review would be the of a continuing process of and improvement all of the It out that to standards the General Medical Council would to on which can only be obtained by and the methods and of medical It to the made by the Association for the of Medical Education and recommended that the Association should be placed on a and many other including and Royal could be by the future regulatory body to for They however, continue to make independent of medical education and their A established and regulatory body will not the of the profession, to the public and to to make its own independent continuing assessment of the of medical education. of the General Medical Council to the Merrison of recommendations made for the of the professional education and training of doctors should have regard to the essential of medical education, and should not by providing and for the supervision of the standards to be required at of training. The of the standard of proficiency required at a qualifying examination as sufficiently to the guarantee of the possession of the knowledge and skill requisite for the efficient practice of medicine, surgery and should be or any is to be of the standard of knowledge and skill which should be by the of the curriculum, it should be should be given to the need for postgraduate training and experience before doctors are recognized as competent to exercise independent judgement in a specialty general and made for some of the standards to be required in the The regulatory body should, the General Council and the General Council, be given a general to standards of professional education. The of the and of the qualifying examination as examination in medicine, surgery, and should be so as to a system of examination and assessment not a examination at the of the curriculum, and to the requirement that such an examination should be held in surgery, and midwifery’. The as to who may be as of medical schools should be some should be under which in the last the Council other regulatory can find a course of or a of examinations and the Privy Council can take appropriate it should be made possible for the Council to schools and examinations and without a of or The regulatory body should be empowered to by or other methods on all relevant to the education and training of a doctor and not be only to relevant to the The statutory the preregistration year should be so is given to bodies to posts as well as to bodies should be given a to withhold of experience that a has held two posts which are not only in themselves but together a midwifery should not be as an in the preregistration a should be laid upon the regulatory body to the standard of experience by the preregistration statutory provisions which have become including those the registration of in public should be in the of should have passed the of whether there to be a for in entry to medical schools and whether the to medicine of by the of and Many have to be taken into in the of medical but, not in countries where the cost of the education is almost entirely by the is the of the extent of the
Language: English
Subfield: Education
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4251887652
Cites: 10
Cited by:
Related to: 8