Year: 2000
Type: article
Abstract: We were pleased that Wasson et al. were so interested in our study as to find it worthy of comment. However, their assertion that our patients were inadequately warmed and without proper analgesia and thus shivering was more frequent cannot go unchallenged. Firstly, we did indeed not actively warm our patients. Wasson et al. find this unacceptable for major surgery and thus question our protocol. However, our study was not undertaken on patients undergoing major surgery (unless one considers laparoscopic cholecystectomy, hernia operations or ankle osteosynthesis as major operations). We apologise for not explicitly stating the types of operations in our paper, but operations lasting on average about 90 min are surely not major. For such operations, we do not have the equipment to warm patients actively as part of routine practice, so there was no difference between study and routine in this respect. The lowest intra-operative temperatures, which were not stated in our paper, were: 35.4 ± 0.5 °C in the nefopam, 35.2 ± 0.5 °C in the clonidine and 35.3 ± 0.6 °C in the placebo group. Temperatures 15 min after extubation (i.e. on arrival in the recovery room) were slightly higher than lowest intra-operative temperatures. The second concern of Wasson et al. is inadequacy of our analgesia regimen (fentanyl 3 μg.kg−1 given intravenously prior to induction of anaesthesia) with 60% nitrous oxide and about 0.4% to 1.6% end-tidal isoflurane intra-operatively, followed by piritramide on demand in recovery. This concern probably also stems from the assumption of the subjects undergoing major operations, but, as already explained, only patients undergoing minor operations were studied. In any case, the patients received as much piritramide in recovery as needed. However, only 40% of the patients in the nefopam group and 30% of the patients in the clonidine and placebo groups needed any piritramide, the highest dose being 22.5 mg. Consequently, it seems reasonable to assume that our fentanyl dosage was adequate in spite of slightly elevated mean arterial pressures after extubation, which were well tolerated in our ASA 1 and 2 patients. Finally, Wasson et al. consider our incidence of shivering in the placebo group to be excessive as a result of the above discussed hypothermia and pain. It should be noted that although 60% of the patients in the placebo group had a shivering score of 1 or higher, this included three patients with a shivering severity of 1 (piloerection or vasoconstriction without visible muscle activity). Without these patients, who would not have been considered as shivering using less stringent criteria, the incidence would have been 45% (well within the range reported in the literature).
Source: Anaesthesia
Authors: S. N. Piper, W. H. Maleck, J. Boldt
Institution: Klinikum Ludwigshafen
Language: English
Subfield: Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Keywords: shivering, intraoperative hypothermia, nefopam, clonidine, piritramide, analgesia, fentanyl, isoflurane, nitrous oxide, minor surgery, postoperative recovery, shivering prevention, patient warming, postoperative pain, postoperative nausea and vomiting, postoperative delirium, postoperative confusion
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4252215448
