Year: 2019
Type: article
Abstract: We appreciate Dr Bronswijk's interest and comments1Bronswijk M. Endoscopic resection of giant colon lipomas: get rid of the roof!.VideoGIE. 2019; 4: 341Google Scholar on our published giant colon lipoma resection case.2Tang S.J. Naga J.M. Endoclip-assisted giant colon lipoma resection.VideoGIE. 2019; 4: 176-178Google Scholar Similar concerns were raised and published before.3Matsushita M, Danbara N, Kawamata S, et al. Endoscopic removal of large colonic lipomas: difficult submucosal dissection or easy snare unroofing? Endoscopy 2009;41:475.Google Scholar We disagree with Dr Bronswijk's suggestion that the unroofing technique should be considered the primary endoscopic technique for all giant colon lipomas. Although unroofing management of GI submucosal neoplasms has been reported, in many cases, complete resection or resolution cannot be achieved. Of the reported cases of colon lipomas treated by the unroofing technique, most patients needed a second-look endoscopy to enable the resection base to be visualized. Even those patients' obstructive symptoms resolved from debulking therapy, and the only scar tissue was seen at the partial resection site; we do not know whether there was any residual lipomatous tissue below the scar. Because there are no long-term follow-up data, we do not know whether those giant lipomas will recur. Tomiki et al4Tomiki Y. Niwa K. Nagayasu K. et al.Two patients with large colonic lipomas for which endoscopic unroofing was ineffective.Case Rep Gastroenterol. 2016; 10: 538-544Google Scholar reported one 2-cm colon lipoma and another 5-cm colon lipoma managed by unroofing. Additional endoscopic resection was required because the initial unroofing was incomplete. Those authors recommended that patients with abdominal pain and hemorrhage should be treated in consideration of complete resection, but not by unroofing, which could leave a residual tumor. The management of symptomatic large and giant colon lipomas should be individualized based on local expertise, the patient's age, and comorbid conditions. If the endoscopists lack certain therapeutic skills and experience, or if the patient is quite senior with significant comorbid conditions, endoscopic unroofing for symptomatic relief is quite reasonable and should be considered the primary option along with a looping and let-go technique. If the endoscopists are skilled at EMR or submucosal dissection and the patient is quite young, endoscopic complete resection should be considered. The author disclosed no financial relationships relevant to this publication. Endoscopic resection of giant colon lipomas: get rid of the roof!VideoGIEVol. 4Issue 7PreviewWith great interest I have read the video case report by Tang and Naga,1“Endoclip-assisted giant colon lipoma resection,” published in the April issue of VideoGIE. The authors describe an alternative technique for resection of giant colon lipomas when classic snare resection or a loop-and-let-go approach is not feasible because of the sheer dimensions of the lesion. In their case, successful resection was performed by means of a needle-knife and clipping of the base. Mild per-procedural bleeding occurred, for which clipping was performed. Full-Text PDF Open Access
Source: VideoGIE
Author: Shou-jiang Tang
Institution: University of Mississippi Medical Center
Language: English
Subfield: Surgery
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $1,200
OpenAlex ID: W4252351523
