Work

Editorial

Year: 1996
Type: editorial
Abstract: In this edition of the Information Systems Journalwe have two papers discussing the impacts of Computer-Aided Systems Engineering (CASE) tools on organizations and a paper on the varieties of the case study research method.In between, we have a paper discussing the use (and non-use) of methodologies to develop information systems.Stephen King's paper provides a study of CASE tool usage in a large UK manufacturing company over a four year period.It shows that tool features and usage are inextricably linked with organizational context and suggests that research into CASE is of limited value if context is ignored.The research approach used is a hybrid of action research, grounded theory and phenomenology.The paper also shows that interpretive research methods can bring to light human and organizational issues which strongly influence systems development practice.The paper by Lars Mathiassen and Carsten Sarensen discusses the problems of CASE technology meeting expectations and they suggest relating CASE introduction to the Capability Maturity Model (CMM).This is a framework for evaluating and improving software processes through organizational learning and intervention based on a systematic collection of experiences and data.The authors conclude that most organizations adopting CASE do not have sufficiently mature software processes to obtain large productivity benefits from using CASE; that not all aspects of a CASE tool need to be utilized in the first phases of CASE introduction; and, like Stephen King's paper, highlights the importance of the organizational context (albeit using a different research approach).Prodomos Chatzoglou and Linda Macaulay report on a survey to find out about the use of information systems development methodologies.Despite the many texts and papers on the subject it will probably be of little surprise to many readers that about half the projects in the survey used no formal methodology, but rather some form of a technique and tool 'kit'.Of those that did use a methodology, most included requirements capture and analysis procedures, which is one focus of the paper.The six most important criteria of those chosing a methodology were identified as ease of use, support, design, management of development process, quality of techniques employed and quality of outputs.Although it is generally accepted in the IS community that there are a variety of relevant research methods, such as action, case study, scientific, contextual, etc., we often assume that each of these methods is well understood, unitary and agreed within their various communities.In fact, there are always alternatives within each method.The paper by Angele Cavaye broadens the concept of case study research among the information systems community by presenting varieties of case research.Using examples from published IS literature for illustra-
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4253991143
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10