Year: 2023
Type: paratext
Abstract: This article examines the literature on women as perpetrators of crime in 19th-century Latin America, a topic largely overlooked in historical scholarship.While most studies focus on women as victims of domestic or sexual violence, this work explores women as perpetrators of crime, specifically reproductive crimes (abortion and infanticide), witchcraft, assault, and murder.In doing so, the article explores how, during the transition from colonial rule to independent republics, politics affected women's status and the law and how women interacted with the evolving legal system.It analyzes scholarly debates on patriarchy, autonomy, submission versus passivity, honor, agency, liberalism, and how the formation of modern states affected women's status.The article highlights how state surveillance of sexuality intensified after independence, culminating in late-century legal codes that codified honor norms and criminalized female behavior.It also considers prosecutions for witchcraft and violent crimes as mechanisms of social control.Scholarship demonstrates that women navigated and sometimes subverted patriarchal structures, ignored the honor code, and aggressively pursued their interests, offering insights into gender, law, and nationbuilding in Latin America's long 19th century. | IntroductionOn April 11, 1841, in the town of San Cristobal in western Venezuela, authorities found Antonio Mendez lying in a pool of blood.He was alive but suffering from five knife wounds, including one that lacerated his spleen.Upon learning that Antonio had just been in an altercation with José María Ibarra, the alcalde (sheriff) arrested José for assault.However, the judge had mistakenly made the common assumption that men, not women, commit violent crimes.Based on new witness testimony, the next day the alcalde released José and instead arrested his wife, Luisa, for assaulting Antonio.This case, then, offers insight into how this highly patriarchal judiciary responded when a woman assaulted a man.In her testimony, Luisa explained that Antonio had, for no apparent reason, verbally insulted her and José, pushed José to the ground, and then hit him with a stick.Seeing that her husband was bleeding, Luisa took action: she attacked Antonio with a knife.After further investigation, the judge concluded that Antonio had a reputation as a trouble maker and acquitted Luisa, given that the attack was justified and not premeditated: "given the fight and the provocations, she acted out of the love that is natural for a wife toward her husband, and under the circumstances there was no time to deliberate … she had no time to consider, in which case she does not deserve punishment." 1 Thus, according to this judicial ruling, in this patriarchal society, a woman could attack a man in order to protect her patriarch.The study of crime in previous centuries is a fairly new field in Latin American history and at this stage we still know little about women and crime.The editors of a 2001 collected volume on the emerging field of crime in Latin American history
Source: History Compass
Language: English
Subfield: History
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4254174887
