Work

Editorial?

Year: 2017
Type: editorial
Abstract: In the humanities, journal decisions usually arrive by post.'So wrote Wendy Laura Belcher in Writing Your Journal Article in 12 Weeks, a guide otherwise full of good sense, and published as recently as 2009. 1 It is easy to scoff at such anachronistic information.But to do so would be to overlook all the seemingly outdated practices and conventions involved in publishing an academic journal, not the least of which is the inclusion of an editorial such as the one you are reading.The majority of TRI articles are accessed online, a process that almost inevitably involves bypassing the editor's introduction, let alone appreciating the order of the articles' appearance within the print copy, or allowing their ostensibly diverse concerns to resonate with and inflect each other.Just before I took over the senior editorship of this journal, I discussed the viability of the editorial with my predecessor, Charlotte Canning, questioning its relevance and necessity.Charlotte rightly pointed out that to give up the editorial would be to relinquish the opportunity to introduce each of the articles in their own right, as well as a platform from which the editor can frame the issue and provide a rationale for decisions made along the way.Underpinning this thinking is something of a paradox, namely that even if journal content is increasingly accessed (in both the practical and interpretive senses) diachronically, as it were, the integrity of each individual article is at least initially reliant on its synchronic appearance alongside a select number of other articles and materials.Accordingly, I wrote my first editorial in the expectation not that it would be read, but that it would be there, in the archive: an exercise in due diligence, available for consultation by my successors as I, in preparation for the role, had read the editorials of those who preceded me.I was pleasantly surprised to discover from personal comments and correspondence that the editorial did indeed have a readership.I subsequently asked a member of the journal's editorial board, Liz Tomlin, to read and review the first issue published under my editorship.Tellingly, the resulting report took the claims and intentions for the issue outlined in the editorial as a way into its wide-ranging reflections and recommendations.Liz took the fact of the editorial to raise questions about how readers access the journal, wondering whether innovation in this area -say, an editorial distributed interstitially between articles to encourage readers to read through from one article to the next -could enhance the integrity of the issue as a whole.And she used the relationship between the editorial and the articles as an opportunity for constructive criticism, noting where greater editorial guidance might have been given to authors, taking issue with some of the claims made in the editorial for those articles, and considering alternative structures to, and rationales for, the issue as a whole.In other words, the editorial renders the editor accountable for their decisions because it is available as an object of critique.And while this is a general observation,
Author: Paul Rae
Language: English
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4255016647
Cites: 1
Cited by:
Related to: 10