Work

Editorial

Year: 2020
Type: editorial
Abstract: It is an honour to take over the editorial reins at the Journal of Quaternary Science at the start of 2020 from Geoff Duller. I do so at a time when human life on the planet is facing an existential threat from the linked crises of a changing climate and ecological degradation. The scientific understanding of these threats has been synthesised by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and the Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystem Services (IPBES), respectively. In both the fourth (2007) and fifth (2014) IPCC Assessment Reports, palaeoclimate studies were represented by a dedicated chapter concerned mainly with Quaternary timescales. They include the ice core record showing a close coupling between atmospheric greenhouse gas concentrations and surface temperatures over glacial–interglacial timescales, the testing of GCM simulations against climates of the last 20 000 years reconstructed from proxy data, and the placing of the instrumental temperature record of the last ~170 years in the longer context of variations over the last millennium. The contribution of Quaternary scientists to IPCC has therefore been both significant and explicit. Quaternary science has also made important contributions to our understanding of the current crisis in biodiversity and ecosystem health. Palaeoenvironmental studies have, for example, provided continuous ecosystem trajectories from pre-instrumental time periods to the present day for lake eutrophication and acidification, for wildfire regimes and for impacts on oceanic island habitats. Nonetheless, in one respect, Quaternary science has failed to transmit a key element of our research to policy makers and environmental managers, namely in debunking the myth of the Virgin Earth. By this, I mean the idea that there once existed a world without human disturbance that can serve as a reference target for future environmental restoration. Such a point in time would have to be sought during the Quaternary era, and yet it turns out to be elusive. Natural history films and television programmes continue to portray an imaginary ‘world without people’; for example, in the struggle between large carnivores and their prey during the latter's seasonal migration across the Serengeti plains of East Africa. Yet cut through those same plains is the Olduvai Gorge, in whose cliff sections have been found some of the earliest evidence of tool-making humans. Homo species and megafauna have therefore co-existed in the African rift valley savanna ecosystem for the past two million years, and they did so in a way that proved sustainable until European colonial conquest. There was no wave of Late Pleistocene megafaunal extinctions in Africa as there was in Australia following the arrival of aboriginal peoples, for example. The Quaternary thus provides us with both good (sustainable) and bad (unsustainable) examples for long-term socioecological relations. In his book Half-Earth (2016) the eminent biologist EO Wilson proposed that ‘only by setting aside half the planet in reserve … can we save the living part of the environment.’ However the Quaternary record tells a different story, namely that a sustainable relationship turns out to be more common when people and nature co-evolved in the same spaces, rather than being kept apart by barriers. This is not to say that the protection given to wildlife in National Parks should suddenly be abandoned, but it does suggest that future solutions should lie in finding ways to make productive lands compatible with maintaining biodiversity. It is not hard to find examples where this is the case, such as the dehesa/montado of southwest Iberia, in which pigs forage in cork oak parkland (and produce the best pata negra ham), a cultural ecosystem that has its roots in the Bronze Age. Emerging archaeological and palaeoecological evidence points to the existence of similarly successful agro-ecosystems in parts of precolonial Amazonia, with the creation of terra preta soils, which offers an alternative land-use model to the current destruction of the Amazon rainforest for cattle ranching and soybeans. Presenting the big picture from Quaternary science to a wider audience, such as the IPBES and IPCC, requires big data synthesis. For Holocene land cover change this is being attempted by collaborative programmes such as PAGES LandCover6k and ArchaeoGLOBE, just as has been done for palaeoclimate via projects such as PMIP. This, in its turn, requires open data stored in accessible archives like PANGAEA and NEOTOMA; journal editors and publishers have an important role to play in ensuring that this is the case. The Journal of Quaternary Science now expects authors to share and deposit their data at the same time as they are published. In a similar fashion, open data also involves a move towards open access to journal articles without paywalls. It is therefore encouraging that our publishers – Wiley – are actively negotiating open access arrangements with a number of national and pan-national bodies, such as projekt DEAL which gives free access to over 700 scientific research organisations in Germany to read and publish in their journals, including JQS. It is my hope that as chief editor I will see JQS fully embrace Open Science while at the same time maintaining high academic standards and avoiding the dangers of predatory journal publishing. In that regard, we are indebted to reviewers who generously share their time and expertise in order to improve the quality of published research in Quaternary science, and whose role remains essential. JQS has been fortunate in having a succession of excellent editors, and my predecessor Geoff Duller is no exception to this trend. We are grateful to Geoff for his splendid editorship of the journal over the past five years, and also to his (and my) two co-editors, Rewi Newnham and Nick Balascio. As a collective team, they have kept JQS on a steady course, and one that I hope can be maintained over the next five.
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,600
OpenAlex ID: W4255196421
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10