Work

g

Year: 1994
Type: editorial
Abstract: It was just 5 years before I was born that Alfred Binet published the first version of a workable appraisal of human intellect.And at almost the same point in time, Charles Spearman enunciated for the first time the model of cognitive functioning as stemming from a pervasive g or general ability factor that entered into all cognitive performances.These were quite independent events, and there is no evidence that Binet and his successors were influenced by Spearman's theorizing, or that Spearman had Binet's test-making activities particularly in mind as he developed his formulation of g and the multitudinous s specifics.But the two developments were congruent in that Spearman's theories gave a type of rationale for the melange of cognitive tasks that Binet and his successors assembled in their test batteries.And jointly, the two events provided the impetus for 90 years of psychometric development.For most of the next 20 years, the focus both of psychometric theory and of test-making practice was on this central general ability.Not all psychologists agreed with Spearman in his concept of a pervasive "mental energy."In particular, Godfrey Thomson at Edinburgh showed that the pattern of test correlations that Spearman relied on as the basis for his concept of g could equally well be accounted for by a sampling theory stating that different tasks sampled relatively broadly from the host of neural connections that could be made in the cerebral cortex, while in a closely related position Edward L. Thomdike viewed the level of intelligence as an expression of the number and richness of neural connections.But whether they explained it as calling upon some pervasive "mental energy" or upon sampling from a supply of neural connections, test makers focused on instruments designed to yield a single score that would represent the examinee's Ediror's Note.The late Robert L. Thomdike (19 IO-1990), whose distingujshed career in mental measurement spanned more than half a century, died on the eve of his 80th birthday, September 21, 1990.Not long before that date, he sent a typescript of this article to Arthur R. Jensen, who recently came across it in his files.He was informed by R.L. Thomdike's son, Robert M. Thomdike, that the article had never been published.Its informal style suggests that it may have been prepared originally for oral presentation.The article's content is especially germane for this journal and, as Robert L. Thomdike's last published work, it is most appropriately presented here as an editorial.
Source: Intelligence
Institution: Columbia University
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,530
OpenAlex ID: W4256045064
Cites: 10
Cited by: 48
Related to: 10