Court of Last Resort
Year: 1952
Type: article
Abstract: A few weeks ago a deputy of William B. McKesson, the District Attorney of Los Angeles County, entered his chief's office bearing disquieting information.The office had convicted an innocent man.The case had, on the surface, been a routine cut-and-dried holdup where a man had been shot.Fortunately, the wound had not proved fatal.Subsequently the police had picked up a suspect who had, of course, claimed his innocence and tried to establish an alibi.As is so frequently the case, the alibi had been supported only by members of the family.Opposed to this alibi, the district attorney's office had produced positive, eyewitness identification.The jury brought in a verdict of guilty, and the defendant went up to San Quentin.Then, some months later, an inadvertent remark by a gangster had put the police on the trail of a different suspect.It was discovered that considerable circumstantial evidence pointed to this suspect and when he was confronted with this evidence he confessed.District Attorney McKesson, a former Superior Judge, was very much disturbed.Upon learning what had happened, his first concern, of course, was to make absolutely certain of the facts in the case.The eyewitnesses who had identified the innocent man were confronted with the second suspect and promptly picked this second suspect out of a line-up, a line-up which included the man who had been wrongfully convicted.Judge McKesson promptly flew to Sacramento to interview Governor Goodwin J. Knight, and to expedite proceedings so that all "red tape" could be cut.Before the information as to what had happened had become public property, the man had been pardoned and released from San Quentin.Now we come to the interesting and, as far as this article is concerned, the significant phase of the matter.Paul V. Coates, the noted newspaper columnist, interviewed both the ":nocent man who had been released from San Quentin and one of the eyewitnesses whose positive identification had done so much to bring about a verdict of guilty.
Author: Erle Stanley Gardner
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W427497275
