Work

What do people care about when managing flood risks? A values-informed mental model approach

Year: 2022
Type: preprint
Abstract: Managing climate risks often requires making hard decisions. While decision analysis can help, many analyses narrowly view what matters to people concerning decision outcomes. For instance, government policies may require projects to pass a cost-benefit analysis in which only easily monetized objectives are considered—incorporating a richer view of people's values means understanding those values and how they intersect with the problem formulations that drive outcomes. Here, we demonstrate an approach for assessing how values influence mental models. We used a case study of household flood adaptation decisions in riverine communities in Pennsylvania, USA. The approach included co-developing a shared mental model with local and academic experts. This mental model then guided interviews with 16 residents. The mental model analysis reveals the diverse values that participants consider when making mitigation decisions. Translating these values into objectives for decision analyses can help decision-makers (i) navigate more relevant tradeoffs and synergies between objectives and (ii) respond to risks in ways that are more consistent with their priorities.
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4293072793
Cites: 51
Cited by: 4
Related to: 9