Work

Attack by a Turkey: Learning to Write History from Bernard Bailyn

Year: 2022
Type: article
Abstract: IN the mid-1980s, Bernard Bailyn, having earlier redefined our understanding of the American Revolution's origins, turned his attention to the great debate of 1787–1788 on ratifying the Constitution. During a year as Pitt Professor of American History at Cambridge University (1986–1987), he wrote a preliminary version of his lecture “The Ideological Fulfillment of the American Revolution,” which he delivered at Oxford University in the Spring of 1987. He gave another version at the American Historical Association Annual Meeting in Washington that December.In 1987, the nation observed the Constitutional Convention's bicentennial. Chief Justice Warren Burger had retired from the Court to lead the commemorative efforts. For Bailyn, however, the important events were the public debates over ratification after the Convention finished its work, not the Convention itself. He was fond of James Madison's comment from 1796, that the Constitution was “nothing but a dead letter until life and validity were breathed into it by the voice of the people”: its meaning would not be found in the Convention at Philadelphia, but in the state conventions which ratified it. Bailyn used this quotation as his epigraph when he republished his own 1987 lecture on ratification in an essay concluding the twenty-fifth and fiftieth anniversary editions of Ideological Origins of the American Revolution.1Bailyn returned to Harvard in the fall of 1987, the same time I arrived as a graduate student. A used copy of the 1967 edition of The Ideological Origins of the American Revolution, which cost fifty cents at the Phoenix Public Library's book sale, had made me think seriously of studying history, rather than continuing on my career trajectory as a cook at the Phoenix Hilton. I came to Boston, finished college at the Harvard Extension School, and in the fall of 1987 enrolled in Bailyn's seminar. Others have written about Bailyn's teaching method and the seminar's format, which did not change from year to year, though the students did. Our cohort did not seem very exciting—there were a lot of awkward silences. Either we were too awed by Bailyn, or too impressed with ourselves, to move the conversation along. Early on he suggested paper topics. The one most intriguing to me was to look into the relationships among the Otis family of Barnstable—a remarkable group that included a diverse array of characters who wrote a lot. Their papers, he told us, were waiting to be mined at the Massachusetts Historical Society. When I went to talk to him about the topic, he was apologetic. One of the students, a visitor from England, had already chosen that one. Why didn't I pick something else?He had also mentioned the origins of the Second Amendment. I had done some research on the Constitution's ratification, thanks to a summer NEH fellowship which had allowed me to examine the role of slavery in the constitutional debates. I went to work on the topic, using the terrific volumes being produced by the State Historical Society of Wisconsin.2 Midway through the semester he began one seminar session sliding an index card across the table to the student on my right, “Here's an article that will be helpful!” Then to the student on my left, “I just found a document you should look at,” and she busily wrote down the citation. Then he gave me a blank look and asked, “What are you working on again?”A week or two later I went to our assigned meeting on the paper. After hearing about my pile of research, he asked, “Why are you writing this?” I sensed that the wrong answer would be, “Because the paper I wanted to write was taken, so you told me to do this one.” So, I said something else—not realizing that this question, “Why are you writing this?” as his “So what?” or “Who cares?” or “What's the news here?” was not about me, but about the topic. It was not the last time he would ask it. This has been a valuable lesson in teaching, as was his constant effort that semester to spark our laggard group into a discussion.Despite my success in not being noticed, or perhaps because of it, he liked the paper I wrote. When I went to see him after the semester, hoping for a recommendation for a Harvard summer fellowship, he said after a few minutes of amiable conversation, “Look, I know you from the seminar, but don't really know enough to write a reference.” As with “Why are you writing this?” I realized the initial response that came to mind—“Thanks for your time”—was not the right one. So, I took as an invitation to tell him more. I mentioned the summer NEH project, researching four or five members of the Convention and their relationship with slavery. More importantly was that I did this while getting my undergraduate degree at the Harvard Extension School, having dropped out of the University of Wisconsin ten years earlier and working for the next decade as a cook. This was more interesting than he expected, and we talked for a bit about researching in the State Historical Society of Wisconsin's Documentary History of the Ratification series, which was then up to eight volumes, and about the characters of some of the people involved in the debate. I did not get the fellowship, though things worked out in other ways.He mentioned that a Harvard alumnus had given Houghton Library some money to mount an exhibit on ratification. They were looking for someone to put it together. He sent me to see Houghton's director, who was delighted to have someone walk through the door ready to put on an exhibit that an alum was pressing them to do. The generous alum, Charles Tanenbaum, was quite excited as well, particularly because Stoddard introduced me as “a student of Bud Bailyn's.” Hearing Bailyn's lecture on ratification at a Harvard alumni event had inspired Tanenbaum to sponsor this exhibit. I had not heard or read about this lecture, and in fact did not know that Bailyn was at all interested in the subject. Nonetheless, that summer I spent my days off from making omelets on Cape Cod putting together an exhibit on Massachusetts Ratification, which opened in September in the Widener Rotunda.3The exhibit opening was an event, mounted by Joan Nordell, the Library's wonderful public affairs coordinator. She organized a viewing with Mr. Tanenbaum and other notables whom I had not met—Sidney Verba and C.Y. Feng from the Library, and others who have since become friends—Henry Lee, Lilian Handlin, and Pauline Maier. Lilian did not attend the opening, but with her husband met us for lunch at the Faculty Club. Oscar Handlin asked me gruffly why he should bother to look at the exhibit? By now I knew my initial answer—“You can do whatever you want”—would not be a proper one, though he had certainly earned the right to do that.One person neither at the lunch nor the opening was Bernard Bailyn. He had sent the organizer regrets, as he was traveling. This was true only in the narrowest sense. As we walked out of Widener's lobby we met him coming in, traveling to his study on Widener's top floor. All were surprised to see each other—he recognized Sydney Verba, C.Y. Feng, Henry Lee, and Pauline Maier before he recognized me, and now was perhaps regretful at not joining us. Probably not. He tended to avoid these kinds of social gatherings, no matter how elevated the after Bailyn with another He in working on the ratification. He had delivered his lecture on ratification the at Oxford and then in I was my seminar at the American Historical in a session by with by and The Library of had him to two volumes of on the ratification debate. As he would this project, and his of the were made by the work being done by the State Historical Society of in and The Documentary History of the Ratification of the Constitution. This had been by at the University of with a The made of all their to the on the had its and not or that year when Bailyn a group of graduate students to read with him on American history, he are to all of I have been as of one are others and you should read and was already in these when he me in to be his research began the most important of my graduate the most important of my since to would not be in the at the same He and on my and I would the to He already had out an for each document he for with that would not the He found through this and among the and coming to know the and of their perhaps than and certainly than he of the same he had in Ideological a continuing over and had with the of four volumes of the of the By the time Bailyn had finished the of the American Revolution, the had into a and the relationship and had the book earned Bailyn the Harvard Faculty and he the in and as Ideological of the other volumes of The in though Bailyn's with the and the year of the Constitution a of The had involved in this debate about the of it be he were at the of the and the Constitution. The was more than one with another or one with one its work the Second when the the working out of in the he asked about his on of the and of the Constitution he these about being It was of a to the Library of he to do more than among the and of their and he to do He to each and the of for of the he was to the he did not. A which Bailyn did not know off the top of his would be, by For Lee, in to James your your were no quotation in the be the for that had it was of the of would have recognized the so to their I had to the that I was by the Bailyn gave me a “I think this he was quite a into the I found a copy of and it Bailyn read over with some not just the but the for her too was a more he wanted to know more. a gave to the on about the should it to a with It was not enough for Bailyn to state was already in the gave this on in to the of the and He more and was to then only in History of the of or the of A of of volumes, Bailyn also wanted other or not. in was to that with was not the had for but in of her and the of her did not that to the in he a that have given to of and I spent in this debate of and One I went to and found Bailyn at his over these volumes which had spent a on the before I them up for his I said something about the to which he “I the his in in writing this essay I turned to the index of The on Ratification to it. a and the of and have made in this nor the are of other are the one did not the Bailyn had spent a of time getting right with though in the of it made it into the Bailyn did not this a of his or he told me his I over the or volumes of The of “I was to he It had not worked and he had a of this that did not and I was that we do not have a for a as a to for a or for a a by or was to other more When a or mentioned a it had to be Bailyn would me to it did the was the I would through the and write out a or so or the Bailyn that I as he found my He would read through I had to his in the and in a or two the so and it he had spent a career it all were so One was the matter of were was was Bailyn sent me into the to I through on and to the of and in the and wrote something was more than a to though I only it all not it, “I don't he wrote on my each and though his study was one of the few on I to avoid he was to ask I not to it on his Our on have on for I would a and he would it not were not out or how to and he perhaps why I not answer so a I was in Widener over and over how I would this when the door he by my as his research I had not met though I knew she was coming in that did not bother to us. He walked my “I you for something and you tell He now his “I don't know why you walked more and to be looking particularly at me this “What do you have a of I just to know are but you tell you have some not to tell before my I she was to the at she to the I worked for Bernard Bailyn I would out of that I he it I being he our of As with I not them in the index of The on the was more in other Bailyn was particularly interested in into the of the the of on his lecture on ratification, Bailyn how Charles and with the and on as a of a his of Bailyn then turned to the of he asked, For was in not nor wrote that of the great will be the or in are for which would be a and of a of with a of of all of it, was the of a the people have and will have the of of the by to a of among of This was for why a of was a of the of on the and would no more than would our Bailyn was interested in than in his and the Bailyn found most wrote that the some who had been to his to who in he Bailyn also through his to from and for and of the one on the in from the and also to the and a and and on this on an with and had been to the and and Bailyn that was to was to the and down the from the the and I knew to in other he had the of For the my and Bailyn's when I found a few the card did not the had been in and in with the more than the The card turned up neither nor or I found on The answer of to the A the of the A on the by essay on the had not been on history, or with He had found in the and as an on and all other This book was the of a that had I Bailyn so I will this to that an to up the this was not to The Library of has its own but The are with a of Bailyn to do this work, each document in but the said The was by and by and though said would the project, would someone to he It was not the time he had with a nor the He would to the as or in to the in an Bailyn turned to the which more than The a of the on was a book that had been in since and that the to and to the of in the of was interested not so in as in his and of others in the debates. who wrote as in his essay on before Madison's took on that only a state have a went in of as a of to all of this in an to the Library of volumes, Bailyn a version of his Ratification lecture in his in of and as an to the twenty-fifth anniversary edition of Ideological which before the Library of volumes in a and that the essay would have been to the these in a History The Constitution of the and by the and Harvard School, in the Spring of and I in on the the his The next time I was a teaching one of four or five by would with Bailyn after lecture for which the took two I how our relationship had A had to a Cambridge for only to to his that Bailyn did not was and the from his own next week was my for on the from the so we on from the in we It turned out that Bailyn did not my of the I now knew Bailyn enough not to be someone not I something that can be have since that he liked He did more for the of about or Bailyn would out a question, by its After a lecture on the of an and with an that would the and into of a from This will into of the and will the at their and will not them in of their it will them to the the and the it will with them when and on all them in their nor will it them in it will the of over his his cook in the the into the and over the and down all he or it will attend him to his and him while he it will of the in his or his it will the in the or in his it will the to his and in his work, and will him in his and in his it will be a constant to the in all his it will be with him in the and in the the of his and the of his it will into the most and it will the of person in the all these of and in all these in which it will attend the which it will them will be asked, A for I came to his were the to our undergraduate for students was He in of the lecture looking at the of and me a or perhaps of their to him up on the for his I the the was were the the two He began each lecture he had said the working his into a of something and from one year to the each was as he through the to it before our One of my who had been by another for his and said to me after Bailyn's lecture, “I Professor was the I had then I heard found some of the more important or than a time when graduate students were on and he had to on of this though he was he did in the of or as A on rather than as social had its but it also one lecture he the of ratifying which to a the to of ratification. A student asked he tell them more. Bailyn up to the and asked me to I went on too and gave too When I he said to the someone who has done a study of the a but I realized Bernard Bailyn had just asked me to something to his By this time I was in the and for the of the the was to be This of constitutional response to the and ratification of the to of his of the it the I began with a of in the volumes, as a or a at a found I the I was working with the of from the my asked Bailyn knew that I not read with a I More was or about whom we know too or of about whom we know very for someone to know I wrote up I off the document on a off the and the for Bailyn to He would it up with and I would him a and he would through it, and we the over of my characters was of not so for his as for the lesson writing his in went to in the then to to This was enough to lead me to James to the in the and a and he ratification at of the me as the most interesting of his One he a on his in the began to A in the the took it for a and the off the it had his of the of with this the the the Bailyn made a through the the next I out some he it all I some the He it all out This and I wrote and he He asked why I putting the I asked why he it as it all was off to our in I delivered a that the would not his The on the Constitution volumes a few years and I them for the a at the Harvard I turned to was at in on of an from an by a It took me to the the only for whom we a of and an or Bailyn us all we to in an from an by a this in Bailyn was The on the and working on The in at the Library of “The to the at the and the the for the for the I was teaching at University and at the Harvard Extension to Cambridge and being on a week gave me to in few I would in, from his on my He interested in I was a I would him he the student who said she was from because her her to time traveling with was the He was of Bailyn as being with the whom were told to why he had not turned in his Mr. Mr. we had the Bailyn he had no response to that one. When American asked me to talk to students about in a I was that recognized this as a career it So, I mentioned it to Bailyn, who said it was not but he in a Bailyn would not see a from the Society for History on Ideological fiftieth I sent it to I had read the before I realized that the in the was Ideological He was I had told him as he it be in to the The role of the a was to to the student at the of the some spent the in the of the writing up their others were more Bailyn at the of the and for would a book or article or a of By this time he had been working on the for a and his were suggested from in and a of to something he had read on his at the of the he told his of working with and also told the graduate students how more their was than his had his he a had only a or so of to through on a topic, while their had of to and to He them to in Bailyn with its He came to the at the and gave a few about He was particularly impressed with the of into the of a with the the he asked for more of the as are also for a introduced to him by his of the of the the next year, and was impressed with the than with his being on a of right Bernard the fall of State University in some American to talk about the of and I and we met for the time in we spent a two about this Bailyn not why our State allowed two to and in I an from the Library of They had asked Bailyn to do an version of the on over to four with rather than in his he the as he was working on History and other He They did not to do as had heard of He told them to They and after I said I do it, asked him to be the while he be the he the I the For the was a for me, being a of a book with Bernard Bailyn was a career the of and with other things on his Bailyn as as on the of the and their He had his on all the included and their had a of and out some of our suggested which of the to we were to or or or we included Otis Warren came out to more for and though Bailyn me about should she not I out one of having a we each had someone to the into and I wrote for each group and a now four with rather than with were about one of us should do an and the other a or we together would write one to him work, I his on in which he talked about the with and it as a He on writing his own as he the Constitution's of and as it had been in his the have been the of the but the more of the book the it would be more in we it did though the the had in were and other of constitutional with them that the would be as most and of the had the to our It was enough that with the of and with which we to Bailyn this to the whom he now in They did not the of the I began to him When the book in we began to each other as I asked him he our next should “What I most about that he a lot of that we can the same about
Author: Robert J. Allison
Language: English
Subfield: History
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4296916469
FWCI:
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10