Year: 2009
Type: article
Abstract: Editor -Hackshaw et al 1 raise some methodologic concerns regarding our re-analysis and suggest on the basis of these that their original analysis 2 leads to a more valid conclusion than our re-analysis.3 The first point raised was that our re-analysis of the intervention studies should have included only randomized controlled trials, implying that because the randomized controlled trial is a more valid study design for causal inference compared with the observational study design, the inclusion of the latter in our re-analysis is likely to be affected by inherent biases and confounding.1 The problem with this argument is that confounding can occur by chance or by indication. 4 When confounding occurs by chance, it will occur with the same probability in randomized controlled trials and observational studies because it is, by definition, due to chance.In both randomized controlled trials and observational studies, the P-value automatically incorporates the uncertainty due to confounding by chance.4 Furthermore, in the context of a meta-analysis, confounding by chance in one direction in one study is expected to be matched by confounding by chance in the other direction in another study.
Source: Clinical Medicine & Research
DOI: 10.3121/cmr.2009.846
Authors: S. A. R. Doi, A. Onitilo
Language: English
Subfield: Statistics, Probability and Uncertainty
Field: Decision Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4298877453
