Year: 1993
Type: article
Abstract: Commenting on Patricia Seed's well-informed and useful review essay (Seed 1991) within a limited number of pages requires selectivity.I will first offer a brief summary of my reading of the essay and then discuss specific issues that have been of concern to me in the past decade.Seed's "Colonial and Postcolonial Discourse" raises two distinctive topics.The introduction and conclusion are devoted to placing colonial discourse into contemporary scholarship and tracing its debts, complicities, and differences with poststructuralism, subaltern studies, new historicism, and feminist theory.In between, five books are discussed, three on Latin America and two on the Philippines.After discussing the five books in terms of current trends in history, anthropology; and literary criticism, Seed offers her overall conclusion: What all these works do to varying degrees is to achieve one of the functions of a critique: to posit an idea about the humanities disciplines-ehistory literary criticism, cultural anthropology-as more than decorative knowledge, as knowledge critical of the relations of authority within a society.The aim of the critique in each of these disciplines is different-economic relations of authority; cultural relations of authority (the canon), conventional political relations of authority.But the basic target of critique remains the same-the relations of authority in colonial and postcolonial states-and it is thus an enterprise of cultural and political criticism being carried out in a resolutely postcolonial era.(P.200)
Source: Latin American Research Review
Author: Walter D. Mignolo
Institution: Duke University
Language: English
Subfield: Anthropology
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4312602458
