Work

The role of meat in the human diet: evolutionary aspects and nutritional value

Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: Aspects of human anatomy, digestion, and metabolism diverged from other primates, indicating evolutionary reliance on, and compatibility with, substantial meat intake. Implications of a disconnect from evolutionary dietary patterns may contribute to today’s burden of disease, increasing the risk for both nutrient deficiencies and chronic diseases. Meat supplies high-quality protein and various nutrients, some of which are not always easily obtained with meat-free diets and are often already suboptimal or deficient in global populations. Removal of meat comes with implications for a broad spectrum of nutrients that need to be accounted for, whereas compensatory dietary strategies must factor in physiological and practical constraints. Although meat makes up a small part (<10%) of global food mass and energy, it delivers most of the global vitamin B12 intake and plays a substantial role in the supply of other B vitamins, retinol, long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, several minerals in bioavailable forms (e.g., iron and zinc), and a variety of bioactive compounds with health-improving potential (e.g., taurine, creatine, and carnosine). As a food matrix, meat is more than the sum of its individual nutrients. Moreover, within the diet matrix, it can serve as a keystone food in food-based dietary interventions to improve nutritional status, especially in regions that rely heavily on cereal staples. Efforts to lower global meat intake for environmental or other reasons beyond a critical threshold may hinder progress towards reducing undernutrition and the effects this has on both physical and cognitive outcomes, and thereby stifle economic development. This is particularly a concern for populations with increased needs and in regions where current meat intake levels are low, which is not only pertinent for the Global South but also of relevance in high-income countries. Historically and from an evolutionary perspective, meat has been cherished by human communities as a nutritious and highly symbolic food, against a 3-million-year background of biosocial needs. Whenever intake was low, this was mostly due to limited access and availability or because of ideological and religious reasons. Today, however, arguments for a widespread reduction of meat consumption have emerged from various actors, mostly in high-income countries. Leaving aside the degree of negative impact that meat may have on a variety of factors that relate to human and planetary health (addressed elsewhere in this Issue; Johnston et al., 2023; Thompson et al., 2023), the purpose of the present article is to summarize the positive nutritional aspects of meat consumption. The outlining, understanding, and weighing of such parameters will be required to enable a proper cost-benefit analysis of any food system transformation, and particularly those that wish to strongly reduce or even eliminate meat intake. Four key questions were identified by the authors of this article as paramount for this discussion and will be addressed below. First, to what degree can meat be considered as a part of the species-adapted diet of humans, and therefore as an appropriate food from a physiological and nutritional perspective? Second, what are the key nutrients that meat provides and could potentially become challenging to obtain from other sources in meat-free diets? Third, what is the current contribution of meat to the global supply of such nutrients and how does that differ regionally? Finally, what would be the implications of a substantial reduction in meat consumption on human nutrition and well-being at large, especially for populations with increased needs and in regions where intake is already worryingly low? Humans and their hominin ancestors have been consuming meat for >3 million years (Mann, 2010, 2018). Dietary divergence of the hominin line from other apes on the African continent was induced by gradual climate change, which resulted in the expansion of drier grasslands and semi-forested regions. Digestible plant foods became less readily available than in wetland forests, but grazing animals were abundant. This led to a dietary shift towards fat and protein, accompanied by the physiological and metabolic adaptations that culminated in modern humans (Figure 1). Overview of the role of meat in human nutrition and of the potential complications if global meat consumption was to be restricted beyond a critical threshold. Ancestral food intake habits have been determined based on a variety of methods, including anthropometry (e.g., cranio-dental changes, suggesting less emphasis on grinding and more on biting and tearing of flesh) and the analysis of the fossil record through a combination of scanning electron microscopy of teeth to reveal microwear patterns, stable isotope analysis in bone and teeth enamel to unravel the trophic level, and exploration of butchery practices, suggesting consumption of ungulate animals. Additional information was obtained using mathematical modeling (e.g., optimal foraging theory), and the study of modern hunter-gatherers as surrogate models of ancestral dietary practices. Due to a process of ‘encephalization’, humans have a larger brain size than would be expected for their body size. To sustain an expansively large brain, energetic compensation was required during hominin evolution. When examining individual organs, the brain mass surplus (and its energy requirement), is closely balanced by the reduction in size (and energy requirement) of the gastrointestinal tract. This is not surprising, considering the gut is the only organ that can sufficiently vary in size to offset the metabolic cost of a larger brain (Aiello and Wheeler, 1995). This process required a shift from a diet high in bulky plants of low digestibility (requiring voluminous fermentation chambers such as a rumen or cecum, or an extensive colon), to a higher-quality diet where foods are more energy dense and require less digestive processing. In temperate grass and woodland environments, this equates to an animal-derived protein-rich and fat-rich diet (Speth, 1989). Based on their digestive system, humans are classified as omnivores, falling between their frugivorous anthropoid relatives (e.g., chimpanzees) and true carnivores. With a simple stomach, relatively elongated small intestine, and reduced cecum and colon, the human gut is suggestive of reliance on a high-quality diet in which meat was predominant. The intestinal length to body length ratio of humans (5:1) is like dogs (6:1) and markedly different to grazing mammals (cattle, 12:1). Another measure of digestive system structure is the gastrointestinal surface area to body surface area ratio, with humans (0.8:1) once again being more similar to carnivores (dogs, 0.6:1) than grazing mammals (cattle, 3:1) (Henneberg et al., 1998). Even compared with their closest evolutionary relatives, the chimpanzees and gorillas, humans have a distinct digestive tract that shows differences favoring reliance on higher-quality foods. The great apes, for instance, have the greatest volume of gastrointestinal tract devoted to the colon (>50%) for the fermentation of low-grade plant materials, compared with humans at <20%. Humans, on the other hand, have a relatively large small intestine similar to carnivores (~70%), compared with the great apes at 15–25% (Milton, 1986). Adding to the above-mentioned anatomical and physiological observations, optimal foraging theory further explains the primordial role of meat in evolutionary diets. Survival depended on adequate daily energy balance, which is a function of the energy content of foods consumed minus the energy spent in obtaining those foods. Despite an abundance of edible (micronutrient-rich) plants in most geographic locations, the energy content of foods available was heavily weighted towards animal foods rich in protein and fat. Examining the dietary patterns of recent hunter-gatherers in terms of energy procurement gives an understanding of dietary practices of our evolving hominin and early human ancestors. In various hunter-gatherer societies, the principal foods providing the bulk of energy were found to be of animal origin. Using 20th-century data from South American hunter-gatherers, the energy return rates from peccary (65,000 kcal/h) and antelope (16,000–32,000 kcal/h) were high, whereas small animals such as squirrels, snakes, and birds still brought in around 5,000 kcal/h. The return rates from roots, fruits, and seeds, however, had a lower range of 500–6,000 kcal/h (Cordain et al., 2002). Even in societies that ranged over plains and jungle environments—having greater access to edible wetland plants compared to open rangelands—heavy reliance on animal foods was common. Analysis of the energy procurement of >200 geographically diverse hunter-gatherer societies show a median energy reliance on animal-sourced foods of around 60% (Cordain et al., 2000). A disconnect from evolutionary dietary patterns may contribute to today’s burden of disease, at least in some age groups (Mann, 2010). This argument is likely to be more consequential during childhood, based on the intensified nutrient requirements for growth and brain development in the early phase of life. Animal-sourced foods, such as meat, are the best source of nutrient-rich foods for children aged 6–23 months (a finding supported by the World Health Organization), leading to compelling benefits on cognitive functions (Balehegn et al., 2019). Drawing on studies from 95 cultural groups, animal-sourced foods—and meat from ungulates particularly—were the most frequently mentioned food groups in child dietary patterns from an evolutionary perspective (Iannotti et al., 2022). Studies examining the health implications for children and youth in the transition from gatherer-hunter-fisher diets to agriculture subsistence reveal nutritional deficiencies, infection, and metabolic perturbations associated with reduced meat consumption and dietary diversity (e.g., Chinique de Armas and Pestle, 2018). It has been argued that public health policies need to assess the above-mentioned evolutionary knowledge when developing food-based dietary guidelines, especially for children (Iannotti et al., 2022). Today, meat has a key dietary role to play based on the density and bioavailability of its nutrients. Restricting its intake would imply that these nutrients will need to be supplied by other foods, or by fortification or supplementation. While this is theoretically possible, it may not be straightforward in practice, due to limitations at the level of resources, culinary skills, dietary culture and habits, or nutritional awareness and knowledge. Food intolerances and allergies (e.g., gluten, soy, or pea protein) further complicate the suitability of meat-free diets. As for all restrictive diets that exclude nutrient-rich food groups, whether by choice or necessity, the impact is particularly relevant for populations with elevated needs, such as children, women of reproductive age, older adults, and individuals in low- and middle-income countries. Below we list the key points of attention that individuals on meat-free diets need to consider. Not all proteins are of equal nutritional value. It is essential to consider the content and digestibility of the indispensable amino acids (IAA) in a food, as these are the nutrients needed to synthesize bodily proteins. By acknowledging these aspects, encapsulated in the term ‘protein quality’, the efficacy of a food as a protein source can be better understood. In practice, protein quality is arguably best described using the Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score (DIAAS; Moughan, 2021). information on the of a food and provides of their true A food is a of or if the are all whereas a lower that only a of the are available for meat, in the range of whereas for most plant proteins are markedly lower and In for range between and which are like but than cereal foods In some are and digestibility is reduced due to plant and the of and factors effects of which can be through with some (e.g., protein-rich plant foods to the source of and When considering the nutritional of protein it is not to consider protein protein sources are not with protein that even an individual the protein intake may be deficient in if the of their diet is of its high meat is an to proteins. Global a protein surplus in all when against The however, may be optimal intake levels for large of the Moreover, these consider protein When for or when considering the bioavailable that protein supply for their populations of were and the bioavailability was to low dietary including access to animal-sourced foods. Although it is often that individuals in high-income protein, that the daily of this the of protein quality and is based on the need to of mass in populations. This however, not an optimal as populations may from intake levels (e.g., the especially in of and in the of or chronic et al., 2022). the protein with plant lower is but dietary for those deficient in protein, the effects of dietary protein quality are particularly for with relatively low energy and for daily protein than the The current understanding of the bioavailability of nutrients in meat is most for protein and amino acids, with understanding for other essential nutrients. of these nutrients are of key for global not least because are to be considered for the human and vitamin B12 to long-chain omega-3 fatty acids, not these nutrients are obtained from animal-sourced foods or are more bioavailable in those foods. In meat a range of other B that can be limited in diets based on cereal including and nutrient levels vary between of meat (e.g., meat, and as as and differences can be further by animal level, and (e.g., at the level of essential fatty are particularly sources of A and and of which the supply is often at the global level, even in high-income et al., 2022). attention has been to iron and as essential with and chronic health for to physical and cognitive physiological and and 2022). minerals are in a range of foods of both animal and plant origin. plant foods often compounds that to these minerals and reduce their (e.g., and is better from animal-sourced foods where it is in a similar to the iron from animals which is more readily bioavailable than the iron found in It has been that the bioavailability of iron and in meat is and as high, as that of like and and 2022). As a further iron intake may be to because other including vitamin A and B vitamins, are needed for iron and Even if have iron the and often even than those of omnivores, this still in lower iron the dietary intake is for adequate To for the above-mentioned differences in bioavailability and to deficiencies, are for individuals consuming diets with and lower animal-sourced food content intake of vitamin B12 is essential for function and The vitamin is critical for with for It is a range of forms in the human which play essential in critical metabolic A range of and health have been to vitamin B12 (e.g., and potentially leading to in and all dietary intake of vitamin B12 is in the of animal-sourced foods, meat being the most fatty acids are a of fatty acids of length and in the human are found in plants in but the and are only found in and are both critical in terms of structure and health for the brain, and also as for a range of that the system and chronic studies show of status, in with cognitive and brain development in The and in most animals theoretically the of the plant omega-3 fatty acids to and in humans this is humans to and from animal et al., and to have lower levels of and in their and a of et al., et al., a spectrum of essential nutrients, meat is a source of various such as taurine, creatine, and potential health relate to and bone and the of and are often in nutritional and still only a of the and range of compounds that can be present in meat, other factors by the of animal and the diet at large et al., impact on health is but to the of the food matrix, against nutritional et al., 2022). Meat is more than the sum of its individual nutrients 2023), for by the and metabolism of other nutrients. A body of the of animal-sourced foods in food-based dietary interventions for the nutritional of as compared to nutrient or et al., This may be by the potential health effects of even compounds that are present in meat, but the likely The bioavailability of nutritional compounds on the food and diet In recent food-based dietary have towards dietary patterns than nutrient or food et al., 2019). This cultural differences within and but also the public health of consuming patterns of food groups within a diet Meat consumed in appropriate levels as a keystone food in this instance, from highly and other forms of in part due to dietary diversity low intake of animal-sourced and a reliance on a for daily energy needs et al., Meat can improve bioavailability particularly in the of diets that are high in (e.g., from Using global food and it has been to how global nutrient supplies from food up to global The has that meat the of the global vitamin B12 as as a of vitamin A mostly from organ and and high of other B and several minerals (Figure et al., 2022). This data be in combination with the of global the has that the supply of vitamin and vitamin B12 global requirements by for contribution all the more This contribution be against the that meat makes up a small part (<10%) of both global food mass and energy, providing further for its nutrient The contribution of food groups to the global supply of nutrients and dietary from food, with all forms of meat for human consumption organ meat and The for protein and the indispensable amino acids have been for bioavailability from the food but not for minerals and for instance, the bioavailability of iron and in meat is and as high, as that of and 2022). from et This global does not In the of meat, the daily consumption is at in South in in the and in high-income in and in and and a in or and et al., 2022). with the intake also show the of undernutrition et al., et al., 2022). are potential nutritional benefits and associated with meat, which vary by and In low- and middle-income particularly in and South meat intake is low, and undernutrition is high et al., 2022). populations could from an increased than reduced meat intake et al., global to meat intake for environmental or other reasons be not to its growth in populations where consumption is already low, as this could hinder progress towards reducing undernutrition and thereby not human and the of economic development (Balehegn et al., 2019). Even in high-income a reduction in meat from current intake levels (e.g., in of risk elsewhere in this Johnston et al., 2023), needs to be considered in with its impact on nutrient and et al., 2022). of the bioavailable foods to women of reproductive age, and and children, and older diets in high-income which to be associated with meat iron the and 2021). women of reproductive age, iron requirements can be challenging to on any diet but the sources of bioavailable the in the of to foods or of these women in the and are deficient in iron of these women in the and in the are deficient in or more et al., 2022). leading to iron may also lower cognitive in women and potentially the development of their studies show an between iron and cognitive and with and which low intake during and is associated with less attention and function in in can to increased and and arguments can be for and vitamin their key role in and brain health et al., et al., 2019). When in deficiencies of these nutrients, physical and cognitive development will be and As argued with to the evolutionary implications of a dietary children have high iron and other nutrient requirements and their development may be with reduced meat intake. Although this would have to be further by a risk several have already their concern when it comes to to a (e.g., the for and for and of In low- and middle-income studies show that the consumption level of animal-sourced foods in is associated with cognitive level, and in children et al., these potentially the of meat in studies is also to improve the and iron of et al., as as the and cognitive of children et al., et al., iron and deficiencies are the most nutritional et al., and meat consumption within a diverse and diet shows potential for these and 2022). Finally, older are at risk of cognitive bone and other effects of that may be by reduced intake of animal-sourced foods. meat in has been to improve essential functions such as health and thereby against et al., Meat is a food, to human nutritional With a role in human it to have a key role in human health and development Removal or large of meat from the as as of where consumption is low, of an individual or of a risk which must be when considering its in food (Figure 1). Moreover, a of may not only with the nutritional complications in this article but may also to environmental As elsewhere in this nutritional benefits not be when its role in the risk of chronic et al., or when environmental et al., the dietary role of meat beyond the of food energy, or even protein, to essential nutrients and bioactive all of which are in a food as a and obtained a in at the where a in food and on food human and animal and food is a of various societies, the of Meat and for Food and a also on various (e.g., the World and the on is a mathematical and in the of human an degree in and a in models for the of the human intestinal current is on modeling and global and food system data to how these can nutrition to individuals and populations. is the of and Global Food of and from the of and the the for which that foods to improve and in African and countries. is a at the Global for to global dietary patterns and how relate to the food system to strategies for how to improve food for human health and environmental a from the of where was a is a in public health at in and of the to and nutrition has in and child nutrition and nutrient deficiencies to and diseases. from the of and a of in from the of as on groups for and was to the in at in and from to as the in the of and Health at the of of the a of in and Food the of at has the of food foods, growth and digestive is of food and human nutrition at the of and was of the Food and at has been the of in food and human including meat consumption and other foods. has a around of human food habits, which has culminated in on hominin meat consumption and a on and human nutrition as a at of
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid:
OpenAlex ID: W4366000205
FWCI: 49.01
Cites: 39
Cited by: 255
Related to: 10