Work

Editor's evaluation: The effects of caloric restriction on adipose tissue and metabolic health are sex- and age-dependent

Year: 2023
Type: peer-review
Abstract: Full text Figures and data Side by side Abstract Editor's evaluation Introduction Results Discussion Materials and methods Data availability References Decision letter Author response Article and author information Metrics Abstract Caloric restriction (CR) reduces the risk of age-related diseases in numerous species, including humans. CR's metabolic effects, including decreased adiposity and improved insulin sensitivity, are important for its broader health benefits; however, the extent and basis of sex differences in CR's health benefits are unknown. We found that 30% CR in young (3-month-old) male mice decreased fat mass and improved glucose tolerance and insulin sensitivity, whereas these effects were blunted or absent in young females. Females' resistance to fat loss was associated with decreased lipolysis, energy expenditure and fatty acid oxidation, and increased postprandial lipogenesis, compared to males. The sex differences in glucose homeostasis were not associated with differential glucose uptake but with altered hepatic ceramide content and substrate metabolism: compared to CR males, CR females had lower TCA cycle activity and higher blood ketone concentrations, a marker of hepatic acetyl-CoA content. This suggests that males use hepatic acetyl-CoA for the TCA cycle whereas in females it accumulates, stimulating gluconeogenesis and limiting hypoglycaemia during CR. In aged mice (18-months old), when females are anoestrus, CR decreased fat mass and improved glucose homeostasis similarly in both sexes. Finally, in a cohort of overweight and obese humans, CR-induced fat loss was also sex- and age-dependent: younger females (<45 years) resisted fat loss compared to younger males while in older subjects (>45 years) this sex difference was absent. Collectively, these studies identify age-dependent sex differences in the metabolic effects of CR and highlight adipose tissue, the liver and oestrogen as key determinants of CR's metabolic benefits. These findings have important implications for understanding the interplay between diet and health, and for maximising the benefits of CR in humans. Editor's evaluation This manuscript breaks new ground in old soil; i.e. sex differences in mouse and human studies and one of the greatest challenges facing translational investigators is the remarkable difference in phenotypes by sex. Defining those differences has been relatively straightforward, but understanding the underlying basis for the phenotypic effects continues to be difficult. This paper demonstrates the sex-and age-dependent effects of calorie restriction on adipose tissue and body composition. It then goes further in describing the metabolic distinctions that arise between males and females. As such, this study will open up new opportunities to explore these sex differences and to test the hypothesis that estrogen in younger animals and humans may be at the center of these effects. Furthermore, it provides a basis for determining why weight loss may be difficult for some individuals with calorie-restricted diets. https://doi.org/10.7554/eLife.88080.sa0 Decision letter eLife's review process Introduction Caloric restriction (CR) is a therapeutic nutritional intervention involving a sustained decrease in calorie intake whilst maintaining adequate nutrition. CR extends lifespan and reduces the risk of age-related diseases in numerous species, ranging from yeast to primates (Lin et al., 2002; Weindruch et al., 1986; Mattison et al., 2017). CR can have detrimental effects, including bone loss (Villareal et al., 2016) and increased susceptibility to infections (Speakman and Mitchell, 2011), and therefore it may not be suitable for all individuals; however, trials of CR in humans show numerous health benefits, including the prevention of cardiovascular disease, hypertension, obesity, type 2 diabetes, chronic inflammation, and risk of certain cancers (Most et al., 2017). Thus, the ability of CR to promote healthy ageing is now also recognised in humans. In addition to these health benefits, many effects of CR reflect evolutionary adaptations that confer a survival advantage during periods of food scarcity (Speakman and Mitchell, 2011). Establishing the extent and basis of CR's effects may thereby reveal new knowledge of healthy ageing and the interplay between food, nutrition, and health. A key contributor to the health benefits of CR is its impact on metabolic function. Ageing is characterised by hepatic insulin resistance, hyperinsulinaemia, and excessive accumulation of white adipose tissue (WAT), particularly visceral WAT (Barzilai et al., 1998; López-Otín et al., 2016; Mancuso and Bouchard, 2019). The latter is coupled with adipose dysfunction, whereby WAT becomes unable to meet the demands for safe lipid storage. This results in ectopic lipid accumulation in the liver and other tissues, contributing to insulin resistance and metabolic dysregulation (Barzilai et al., 1998; Mancuso and Bouchard, 2019). CR counteracts these effects, decreasing WAT mass, increasing fatty acid (FA) oxidation, preventing ectopic lipid deposition and enhancing insulin sensitivity and glucose tolerance (Speakman and Mitchell, 2011). Notably, studies in rodents show that removal of visceral WAT, independent of CR, is sufficient to prevent insulin resistance, improve glucose tolerance and increase lifespan (Gabriely et al., 2002; Muzumdar et al., 2008; Tran et al., 2008). Visceral WAT loss in humans is also strongly associated with CR's metabolic benefits (Larson-Meyer et al., 2006). Thus, the ability of CR to decrease visceral WAT, and the resultant improvements in hepatic insulin sensitivity, are likely central to CR's effects on metabolic function and healthy ageing. This importance of adiposity and metabolic function raises the possibility of sex differences in the CR response. Indeed, it is now well established that metabolic homeostasis and adipose biology differ substantially between males and females (Mauvais-Jarvis, 2018; Oliva et al., 2020; Valencak et al., 2017; Maggi and Della Torre, 2018); however, most preclinical rodent studies have used males only (Prendergast et al., 2014), suggesting that much of the CR literature may have overlooked sex as a potential determinant of CR's effects. Nevertheless, some clinical and preclinical CR studies from our lab and others have identified sexually dimorphic responses (Kane et al., 2018; Redman et al., 2007; Shi et al., 2007; Cawthorn et al., 2016), whereby males lose fat mass to a greater extent than females. Oestrogens underlie many metabolic sex differences (Mauvais-Jarvis, 2018; Della Torre et al., 2018), suggesting that oestrogen may contribute to females' resistance to fat loss during CR. However, the extent and basis of sexual dimorphism in CR's metabolic effects remains to be firmly established. Herein, we first systematically review the CR literature to establish the degree to which sex has been overlooked a determinant of the CR response. To further elucidate the extent and basis of sex differences, we studied CR in male and female mice and humans at ages where oestrogen is physiologically active or absent. Together, our findings show that the CR field has largely overlooked sex differences and reveal that both mice and humans display age-dependent sexual dimorphism in the metabolic effects of CR. Results Sex is routinely overlooked as a biological variable in the CR literature One review of the recent CR literature found that most rodent studies use males only, with females typically used only to address female-specific experimental questions (Kane et al., 2018); however, the extent of this bias in earlier CR studies, and whether it applies to human CR research, has not been assessed. To address these issues, we first systematically quantified the use of males and females, and the consideration of sex as a biological variable, in mouse and human CR studies (Figure 1, Figure 1—figure supplement 1). We focused on research published since 2003, when the European Commission first highlighted the importance of addressing sex as a biological variable (Lee, 2018). We also excluded studies that necessarily focused on a single sex, such as those addressing effects of CR on female reproductive function, leaving only studies in which there is no scientific rationale for ignoring potential sexual dimorphism. We found that male-only studies predominated for mice, accounting for ~64% of all mouse CR studies since 2003 (Figure 1A, Figure 1—figure supplement 1B). This is consistent with previous analyses of the more-recent CR literature (Kane et al., 2018). Fewer than 20% of studies used females only, while around 7.3% combined males and females, suggesting an assumption that sex would not influence experimental outcomes. In contrast,~60% of human studies combined males and females, while ~23% used only females and ~12% only males (Figure 1C, Figure 1—figure supplement 1B). Strikingly, by the end of 2021, studies that included both sexes and analysed data with sex as a variable were in a minority for both mice (~3.4%) and humans (~4.5%) (Figure 1A and C). Moreover, the proportion of studies using each sex or combination of sexes has remained relatively constant since 2003 (Figure 1A and C). Thus, efforts to increase the consideration of sex in experimental design, as promoted by the European Commission (Lee, 2018), Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) and National Institutes of Health (NIH) (Johnson et al., 2014), appear to have had little impact on the field of CR research. Figure 1 with 1 supplement see all Download asset Open asset Summary of sex differences in mouse and human CR research. PubMed was searched using MeSH terms to identify research articles that studied caloric restriction in vivo in mice (A,B) or humans (C,D), published between 2003 and 2021. Search results were then classified into the following groups depending on the sexes included in each study: 'Male only'=male subjects used exclusively; 'Female only'=female subjects used exclusively; 'Male & Female separate'=male and female subjects used with data reported respective to each sex, allowing sex differences to be addressed; 'Male & female combined'=male and female subjects used with data from both sexes combined either in part or in full; 'N/A'=no sex data available. (A,C) Cumulative publications for studies within each group. The boxes between (A) and (C) highlight the dates of funders' policies highlighting the importance of sex as a biological variable. (B,D) Pie charts of those studies in the 'Male & Female separate' group that considered sex a biological variable, and the proportion of these that did or did not detect sex differences. Source data are provided as a Source Data file. See also Figure 1—figure supplement 1. Figure 1—source data 1 Literature search to identify sex differences in mouse and human CR research. Values for the data presented in Figure 1A–D are shown in the file named 'Figure 1_Source_Data.xlsx'. Raw data for the literature searches for mice and humans are contained in the files named 'Literature_Search_Mice.xlsx' and 'Literature_Search_Humans.xlsx'. https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/88080/elife-88080-fig1-data1-v2.zip Download elife-88080-fig1-data1-v2.zip We next focused on the minority of studies that did consider sex in their experiments ('M&F separate') and that included analysis of metabolic parameters. We found that results in ~74% of mouse studies (Figure 1B) and ~62% of human studies (Figure 1D) indicated a sex difference in the CR response. Thus, sex differences have been described in the CR literature, but the continuing dearth of studies that include both sexes suggests that this issue continues to be overlooked in the CR field. Females resist CR-induced weight loss and fat loss To explore sex differences in the CR response, we assessed the effects of 30% CR, implemented from 9 to 15 weeks of age, in C57BL/6 J and C57BL/6 N mice. As expected, CR decreased body mass in both males and females (Figure 2A) but this effect was greater in males, with ANOVA confirming a significant sex-diet interaction. This sex difference in response to CR is particularly clear when body mass is presented relative to baseline, pre-CR levels (Figure 2B). Figure 2 with 4 supplements see all Download asset Open asset Female mice resist weight loss, fat loss, and lipolysis during CR. Male and female mice on a C57BL/6NCrl or C57BL/6 J background were fed ad libitum (AL) or a 30% CR diet from 9 to 15 weeks of age (0–6 weeks of CR). (A–F) Each week mice were weighed (A,B) and body composition was determined by TD-NMR (C–F). Body mass, fat mass, and lean mass are shown as absolute masses (A,C,E) or fold-change relative to baseline (B,D,F). (G) The mass of gWAT (gonadal WAT) was recorded at necropsy and is shown as % body mass. (H,I) Micrographs of H&E-stained sections of gWAT (H) were used for histomorphometric analysis of adipocyte area (I); in (H), scale bar = 100 µm. (J) Plasma was sampled at 15 weeks of age and the concentration of non-esterified fatty acids (NEFA) was assayed. (K,L) At 10 weeks of age, during the period of maximal weight and fat loss, a separate cohort of mice were culled and iWAT was collected for analysis of the indicated proteins by Western blotting. Fluorescent Western blots (K) were quantified using LICOR software (L); L=protein ladder. Data in (H) and (K) show representative micrographs (H) and immunoblots (K). Data in (A–F) are shown as mean ± SEM of the following numbers of mice per group: male AL, n=42; female AL, n=43; male CR, n=44; female CR, n=52. Data in (G), (J) and (L) are shown as violin plots of the following numbers of mice per group: male AL, n=29(G), 13 (J) or 11 (L); female AL, n=28(G), 14 (J) or 10 (L); male CR, n=33 (G), 14 (J) or 11 (L); female CR, n=34 (G) or 13 (J,L). Data in (H–I) are shown as representative micrographs or violin plots from 5 (male AL) or 6 (female AL, male CR, female CR) mice per group. For (A–F), significant effects of diet, sex and/or time, and interactions thereof, were determined by three-way ANOVA or a mixed-effects model. For (G), (J) and (L), significant effects of diet and/or sex were determined by two-way ANOVA with Tukey's or Šídák's multiple comparisons tests. For (I), significant effects of diet and/or sex on adipocyte area (Ad.Ar) were determined using a mixed-effects model, while significant differences in median Ad.Ar between AL and CR mice were determined two-way ANOVA with Šídák's multiple comparisons test. p Values from ANOVA or mixed models are shown beneath the graphs, as indicated. For (G), (I), (J) and (L), significant differences between comparable groups are indicated by * (p<0.05), ** (p<0.01), or *** (p<0.001). Source data are provided as a Source Data file. See also Figure 2—figure supplements 1–4. Figure 2—source data 1 Female mice resist weight loss, fat loss, and lipolysis during CR. Values for the data presented in Figure 2A–G1–J and L are shown in the file named 'Figure 2_Source_Data.xlsx'. Raw uncropped images of immunoblots in Figure 2K are shown in the files named 'Figure 2 blots lower beta-actin.tif', 'Figure 2 blots lower HSL.png', 'Figure 2 blots lower P-HSL.png', 'Figure 2 blots upper beta-actin.tif', 'Figure 2 blots upper HSL.png', and 'Figure 2 blots upper P-HSL.png'. Annotated images of uncropped immunoblots from Figure 2K are shown in the file named 'Figure_2 K_Uncropped_blots.eps'. https://cdn.elifesciences.org/articles/88080/elife-88080-fig2-data1-v2.zip Download elife-88080-fig2-data1-v2.zip To determine how fat and lean mass contribute to these diet and sex effects, body composition was assessed weekly using time-domain nuclear magnetic resonance (TD-NMR; Figure 2C–F, Figure 2—figure supplement 1A–B). CR decreased fat and lean mass in males, whereas females maintained fat mass and lost only lean mass (Figure 2C–F). A significant sex-diet interaction was apparent for absolute fat mass (Figure 2C) and for fat mass relative to baseline (Figure 2D); the latter showed that CR decreased fat mass in males, whereas AL males and AL or CR females increased fat mass to a similar extent over the 6-week duration (Figure 2D). For lean mass, a significant sex-diet interaction occurred for absolute mass, with losses being greater in males than in females (Figure 2E). However, when compared to baseline lean mass, the CR vs AL effect was similar between the sexes, in part because AL females continued to increase lean mass over time (Figure 2F). Given that these body composition changes coincide with changes in overall body mass, we also assessed fat and lean mass as % body mass. Males preferentially lost fat mass and preserved lean mass in response to CR, with % lean mass being greater in CR vs AL-fed males (Figure 2—figure supplement 1A–B). In contrast, diet did not alter % fat or % lean mass in females, indicating that changes in body composition were proportionate to the overall changes in body mass (Figure 2—figure supplement 1A–B). To determine how these changes relate to regional adiposity, we measured adipose depot masses after 6 weeks of AL or CR diet (Figure 2G, Figure 2—figure supplement 1C, Figure 2—figure supplement 2A). We found that in males but not females CR decreased the absolute mass of gonadal (gWAT), inguinal (iWAT), mesenteric (mWAT), and perirenal (pWAT) WAT depots, as well as brown adipose tissue (BAT; Figure 2—figure supplement 1C). CR also tended to decrease the absolute mass of pericardial WAT (pcWAT) in males only (Figure 2—figure supplement 1C). To determine if these changes were proportionate to changes in overall body mass, we further analysed the mass of each adipose depot as % body mass (Figure 2G, Figure 2—figure supplement 2A). This showed that the significant sex-diet interaction persisted for gWAT, iWAT, mWAT and pWAT. CR did not affect % BAT mass in either sex, although % BAT mass was significantly greater in males than in females (Figure 2—figure supplement 2A). Thus, both in absolute terms and as % body mass, CR decreases WAT mass in males but not in females. We next analysed the masses of other tissues to determine if this sex-dependent effect of CR is unique to WAT. CR significantly decreased the absolute mass of the liver, pancreas, kidneys, gastrocnemius muscle (gastroc), heart, spleen, and thymus (Figure 2—figure supplement 2B). Significant sex-diet effects were detected for the liver and kidney, with CR causing greater decreases in males than in females; however, for each of the other tissues the CR effect was similar between the sexes (Figure 2—figure supplement 2B). In contrast to these effects on absolute mass, CR did not significantly affect the relative masses of each of these tissues, nor did sex influence the CR effect (Figure 2—figure supplement 2C). This indicates that the absolute masses of these tissues decreased in proportion to the changes in overall body mass. One notable exception is the adrenal glands, the mass of which was increased with CR to a greater extent in males than in females (Figure 2—figure supplement 2B–C). Together, these data show that the sex differences in CR-induced loss of body mass and fat mass are driven primarily by decreased WAT mass in males, which females robustly resist. Females resist adipocyte hypotrophy and lipolysis during CR Differences in WAT mass can be driven by changes in adipocyte size and/or adipocyte number. Thus, given the marked sex differences in the effect of CR on WAT mass, we next investigated this effect at the level of adipocyte size (Figure 2H–I, Figure 2—figure supplement 3A–B). CR significantly decreased average adipocyte area in males but not in females, both for gWAT (Figure 2H–I) and for mWAT (Figure 2—figure supplement 3A–B). This suggests that females resist lipolysis during CR. Consistent with this, CR increased in males but not in females (Figure To further adipocyte lipolysis, we analysed of in CR in males but not in females (Figure Figure 2—figure supplement Moreover, both was lower in females whereas was increased by CR in females only (Figure Figure 2—figure supplement Together, these show that females resist lipolysis during CR. Females energy expenditure and increase postprandial than males during CR We next investigated if altered energy expenditure also to the sex differences in the CR response. To we used to mice during week 1 and week of CR, to periods of weight loss and weight (Figure 2A). This that CR decreased energy expenditure in both sexes, with greater decreases during week compared to week 1, and during compared to (Figure 3A–B). Notably, during week 1, CR females had lower and energy expenditure than CR males (Figure likely females' resistance to weight loss and fat loss during the first week of CR (Figure The diet differences when to lean body mass (Figure supplement suggesting that are driven primarily by the loss of lean mass and a in metabolic In contrast, CR decreased in and energy expenditure when to lean body mass (Figure supplement The between lean mass and energy expenditure did not differ the however, the of the did differ both during week 1 (Figure and week (Figure supplement 1B). Thus, for a given lean body mass, males and females had significantly lower energy expenditure than their AL-fed (Figure Figure supplement 1B). In contrast to these decreases in energy CR increased and activity in both sexes, with CR females higher activity than CR males during week 1 (Figure supplement 1C). Together, these data show that CR decreases energy expenditure in females than in males, increasing and that decreased lean mass contribute to this CR Figure with 2 supplements see all Download asset Open asset CR decreases energy expenditure and postprandial in female than in male mice. Male and female mice were fed AL or CR as described for Figure In week 1 and week after AL or CR mice were for 4 in for expenditure and was recorded the 4 energy expenditure (A) or per over the and on the average for of for 1 and energy expenditure during the or for 1 and (C) of lean mass vs energy expenditure during 1. in 1 and during the postprandial from to for CR mice. (G) was determined on energy expenditure and as described et al., Data are from 10 (female 9 (female CR, male AL) or (male CR) mice per group. In (A) and data are shown as mean ± In and data are shown as violin plots with data within each time period or significant effects of sex, diet, and interactions thereof, were determined by three-way or two-way ANOVA with p shown beneath each significant differences between comparable groups were further assessed by Šídák's or Tukey's multiple comparisons and are indicated by * (p<0.05), ** (p<0.01), or *** (p<0.001). For in was used to test if the between lean mass and energy expenditure significantly all of the groups between AL and CR mice, of sex AL vs CR and between males and females fed AL diet or CR diet p for differences in and are reported beneath the See also Figure supplements Figure data 1 CR decreases energy expenditure and postprandial in female than in male mice. Values for the data presented in Figure are shown in the file named 'Figure Download We next analysed the to how diet and sex influence and lipid oxidation, and if these effects differ as CR In AL mice, during the when most food and activity in contrast, for CR mice from to in the following of the of CR diet (Figure Figure supplement 2A). The effects of CR on average or did not differ between the sexes (Figure Figure supplement however, the changes in during these and the influence of and on in the CR mice, such average difficult to Thus, we further investigated if in the postprandial and/or between CR males and females. as the average from to 1 in both sexes (Figure and indicating that CR mice use for et al., Notably, this postprandial was greater in females than in males, particularly during week 1 (Figure as the average from to was for both sexes, indicating of than during this (Figure supplement 2B). was lower during week 1 than during week of CR for postprandial no sex differences were (Figure supplement 2B). This suggests that relative lipid is greater in the first week of CR and is similar in males and females. However, given that females have lower absolute energy we that would also have lower absolute et al., As shown in Figure and Figure supplement CR increased absolute in both sexes during week 1, but not during week both there was a significant sex-diet with CR increasing in males than females (Figure Together, these data show that females have greater postprandial and lower absolute than males, particularly during the first week of CR. This further which females fat mass during CR. Females resist CR-induced improvements in glucose homeostasis We next investigated if other metabolic effects of CR also differ between the sexes. We found that CR decreased blood glucose to a greater extent in males than in females (Figure Consistent with this, glucose tolerance that CR improved glucose tolerance in both sexes, but this effect was greater in males (Figure These diet and sex effects were by the area the blood however, were not apparent for the blood glucose for each mouse (Figure This suggests that differences in glucose are the of CR-induced improvements in glucose tolerance and the sex differences Figure 4 with 1 supplement see all Download asset Open asset The effects of CR on glucose homeostasis differ between young male and female mice. Male and female mice were fed AL or CR diet from 9 to 15 weeks of age, as described for Figure (A) blood glucose was recorded each At 13 weeks of age, mice an glucose tolerance test glucose during the (C) the during the was determined relative to and relative to baseline insulin in mice during was assessed using an insulin and of mice from glucose and insulin during the Data in and are presented as mean ± Data in (C) and are presented as violin plots with data For each group and the following numbers of mice were male AL, or female AL, or male CR, or female CR, 1, or male AL, female AL, or
Source: eLife
Author: Mone Zaidi
Language: English
Field: Medicine
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,500
OpenAlex ID: W4381461411
Cites: 123
Cited by:
Related to: 10