Personal data and personal safety: re-examining the limits of public data in the context of doxing
Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: Doxing is a form of cyber harassment that involves the malicious collection and dissemination of personal information, often resulting in threats of violence, loss of employment, and other negative consequences. As social media usage has increased, people have become more willing to share personal information. This trend has made it easier for cyberbullies to collect and share either public or private personal information and publish it online to cause harm. However, people should be able to use the Internet without fear of physical or psychological harm. This article provides various definitions of doxing and explains the methods that are commonly used in doxing. This article examines the criminal offenses of different countries, including the USA, EU, and Turkey, to explore the existing legal framework and identify potential remedies for punishing and preventing the disclosure of personal information with malicious intent. Furthermore, it illustrates how data privacy law, can be used to combat doxing under the purpose limitation principle. Finally, the article emphasizes the importance of the legal values that are threatened by doxing and proposes a perspective for future doxing legislation. Andrew Anglin, the editor of a magazine that sympathizes with neo-Nazis, published photos, phone number, e-mail, and social media profiles of Tanya Gresh, a wedding organizer for the Jewish community, on the largest neo-Nazi website.1 After that, Gresh's phone kept ringing, she received countless death threats and anti-Semitic messages. Furthermore, Gresh was forced to delete all of her social media accounts. She had to hire security guards to be stationed outside her house. But the threats did not stop. Following that, Gresh began to experience panic attacks, and her physical health deteriorated. In her own words, ‘What they did to me wasn't harassment, it was terrorism, they took away everything in my life’. Gresh sued Andrew Anglin for violating her privacy and causing mental and emotional distress under the Anti-Intimidation Act. Anglin was sentenced to pay $14 million as compensation.2 Gresh said that if there was an anti-doxing law, maybe this attack would never have happened to her.3 This case highlights how exposing sensitive information about individuals on the Internet with malicious intent can bring the dangers of the online platform into the physical world.4 Many countries have enacted criminal offenses and published legal guidelines to combat cyber harassment. Recently, Hong Kong’s legislature enacted an amendment to privacy law that directly addresses the public release of information identifying an individual or organization.5 On the other hand, the European Union (EU) has implemented its General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)6 since May 2018 to give users more control over their personal data online, including the right to be forgotten, which can be used by targets of doxing to have personal information removed from search engine results. In addition to cybercrime regulations in its Criminal Code, Germany has also implemented the Facebook Act in 2018, which imposes heavy fines on social media platforms that fail to remove hate speech, fake news, and illegal content within 24 hours of its posting.7 The Crown Prosecution Service, an independent organization that prosecutes criminal cases that have been investigated by the police and other investigative organizations in the UK, released detailed guidelines for prosecutors on what constitutes criminal online harassment.8 Turkey has also enacted an anti-stalking statute. In the USA, there are currently few legal remedies for the victims of doxing. While these approaches may be implemented to address particular cases, they may not provide complete protection against doxing in practice. Doxing is a multifaceted issue that includes a wide range of methods and technologies and requires a comprehensive approach. This article will begin by providing a definition of the term ‘doxing’ and an overview of the methods utilized by cyberbullies. Subsequently, the criminal framework of Turkey, the USA, and the EU region will be analysed to highlight the advantages and limitations of these frameworks in combatting doxing, together with those of some selected other countries. While individuals may choose to publish personal information about themselves on the Internet, the question remains whether this always justifies the collection and distribution of publicly available personal information with malicious intent. This article aims to emphasize the importance of protecting personal data used in doxing, even if that data are publicly accessible. To support this argument, the purpose limitation principle in data privacy law will be examined. Since doxing not only violates privacy but also jeopardizes many legal values, this article will propose a new perspective for future doxing legislation. There is no legal definition of doxing. The term ‘dox’ is derived from the slang ‘dropping dox’, an old revenge tactic that emerged in 1990s hacker culture.9 Scholars have provided various definitions of doxing. According to Professor Mary Anne Frank, the definition of doxing is the public release of an individual’s private, sensitive, or personal information, such as home address, email address, phone number, social security number, and employer contact info, family member’s contact information, photos of the victim’s children and the school they attend.10 Sarah Jeong thinks that doxing means the publication of a physical residential address, or information protected by law.11 Gabriella Coleman defines doxing as the leaking of private information such as social security numbers, home addresses, or personal photos. In addition, she does not limit doxing to legally protected information.12 On the other hand, The Oxford References Dictionary describes doxing as an online practice of exposing personal information about others which had previously been kept private.13 The European Institute for Gender Equality defines ‘doxing’ as the online gathering and dissemination of private information on the Internet in order to publicly expose and shame the person being targeted.14 According to McIntyre, doxing is a type of harassment that occurs when someone publishes private information (usually through a deep Internet search or hacking) such as a phone number, home address, or social security number and publishes that information online without permission.15 Extortion, coercion, and harassment can all be made easier with the release of this information.16 Doxing can take place in different methods and for numerous purposes. According to MacAlister, doxers typically have three different intentions. She distinguishes three types of doxing based on the actor’s intent: punching down doxing (ie, doxing for purely malicious purposes), doxing for political purposes, and the use of doxing as a tool for internal regulation by members of anonymous online communities (ie, unmasking).17 Douglas, on the other hand, distinguishes three types of doxing based on the type of information revealed and the and provides detailed information that an individual’s anonymous or to their information about an individual that can be used to such as their home address or or information about an doxers against a of people in are of the that have been to are in However, doxing is not of the magazine In this form of doxing, someone sensitive information about such as information, addresses, social security numbers, or phone to cause or loss of such as and have all been by the people with As a of this of doxing, people such as loss of loss of employment, harassment, physical or in an was as the of the by on Following that, and a was in the a and death was a use doxing as a tool for revenge on their This is To give an a to take revenge on those made about on in down the people the fake and their After that, some of their sensitive information on the Following was from and was from of the cyberbullies of being for doxing and to and on social Doxing when cyberbullies their victims to the police for the purpose of or to or cause to they the police the and the police a to the in three the in in her with her her that they have received an anonymous phone that there is an doxing is the type of doxing they use and against the is often for purposes, it can also be used as a tool for such as In doxing, release personal information about their on the Internet and others to The may be personal revenge or or a particular or In a by a fake and her photos, personal and contact information without her used the to and photos and to other resulting in and to her to to the fake her against which to of under law, was by the doxing is a as the online and has become to the use of and social media As a to combat doxing, it is to that such In this the will various approaches that can be used to combat doxing, based on the of different countries. To there is currently no in the that Scholars that doxing is directly to the and that a be privacy and of often themselves by they are their right to While the from that of have that of does not have In the case of a of may be under the of a The of the will be by the to whether the is a or this it can be that doxing may be a and can be under the to the The Act and other and content that is to children on the Internet, with in of criminal law and The no or of an be as the or of information provided by information content be as the of that users to the In other words, online that or are from a of that legally for what others and or users of be for the content by users or others share the content of Furthermore, these are not to whether the content is illegal or not if they are not as content As a of this in the not be under the for users The the Internet of to person or to the person of that the threatened does not to the prosecutors use to in with this to the and and However, only threats to or a In many cases of doxing, an may never to or the Doxing may the and a few contact information, but the may be In other words, the can cause or the without or On the other hand, doxing occurs not only with the purpose of or but also for other such as loss of The the use of in a of that a person in a fear of death or or emotional distress to a The requires intent to or place under with intent to or requires a of for of is as of of or more The has the potential to be a tool for preventing some of doxing, but it is of its of with the and others was only for or particular no person be of the of under On the other hand, the that over three million people are online the in the of only about three of those it can be that these not provide and their are and they are in doxing. has been to the as a the law amendment on May that person a to person or is about the of themselves or of their by or to contact by or information or by be with a term of from to to some of doxing, it is not to provide a against doxing for requires such as or to the either or However, doxers can their victims without or or contact with whether can be used to malicious doxing on whether the constitutes a of The of emphasizes that such as or to should can cause to their targets without or to contact of the that person with the intent of people and by phone or other for the be with a term of from three to the of the does not limit the of that means to and will this doxing be an may be used for doxing However, also does not provide a against doxing for of under it is to a few phone or for a of requires of as a of the the be As in doxing cases, the can the with a few Furthermore, under the be and doxing may be with the intent of or As a the and of of limit the for there are offenses that can be against doxing cases, it can be that there is no law that directly doxing in the The Crown Prosecution cybercrime a number of offenses that be to including a death private without or which may to the of a of a and or of offenses be as a of these offenses not directly doxing and only in and The highlights the Act and the Protection from Act for of the it an for a with the of causing distress or to to person that an or or are themselves of an or or a or information that is and or to be by the The and has as The be to those to it or that was the of that it be to be by a of the public or In the the to have been the have or been that the was not but The that the was in even was not for an to this the they be many doxing cases an with of a and her on the to the some of may only the contact information. As a cases of doxing that not are not under the of a provides a of that are with including a or to a person by means or other to or to to or to from a the is not that may various to be even if they are not on the According to in order to there should be This means that there be a of that to harassment, and that particular harassment can be as However, doxing may on the in have a to doxing, as doxing can limitations to the of In addition, doxing the cyberbullies to or the without or existing may to some doxing cases, but it does not provide an and legal for many of doxing. Data also as constitutes a criminal to of the Criminal data that are protected against with not three or In order to the the information without and the data for or to cyberbullies not to information in order to their doxing cases that not a attack will not be under According to in order to the either data for themselves or it to that or in some other to that take place for the purpose of However, no is to these it can be that, in doxing, cyberbullies also that are in and can be used against doxing. However, it should be that the data should be accessible. an may in doxing cyberbullies use data that have been released by since or of has been a criminal to of the Following the of in it was illegal to the without of such The that the the and the of the is the of the of and that can be under such as person in a to not that to contact with the other person by means of or other means of or through the other personal data for the purpose of to contact with that and the other of or her or someone to or her with causing to or physical or are in The requires a intent to the This involves the to the victim’s that the in are not and can be through According to the for the law, is to or which is not always by However, in cases, may not to doxing, since requires a of in order to the other Hong has enacted an amendment that addresses doxing. The Data was published in the Hong on with the of doxing and the to take against of the defines the of of personal data without the of data as the person an if the person personal data of a data without the of the data an intent to cause to the data or family of the data or as to whether would or would to the data or family of the data To combat doxing, does not a of in order to a that the be with intent to cause harm. it provides if the disclosure is for new or in the public there is a and the personal information of the was under the the and the personal information of people to an that is under in a and it However, in the that their was to the not On the other hand, or including personal information that to may also be under this which be used to in order to a protection of privacy and of speech, it should be how the to will be also requires the disclosure should be made without the data and the disclosure should cause a harm. According to the term a of negative or that are including harassment, psychological and causing the to be about their give it does not how should be The of the may be to be in this The the use of personal data for new purpose that is not to or to the purpose when the with the data and In addition, data can their previously by Furthermore, the data should their purpose of the personal data to the data is not to that an individual to someone information about themselves that it can be used against for malicious purposes. not that to personal information will be in practice. it can be that the directly addresses doxing and to be an against However, doxing is directly to data privacy law as it involves or personal data and or it Data privacy law be the of personal that the data be only for and not used for other without the often that doxing is not illegal since the data used for doxing such as photos, or phone is made public by individuals on the However, the purpose limitation which is a of data privacy law, the This principle that personal data can only be and used for purposes, and malicious dissemination of such information is a of privacy In data privacy law, the of data are in the Data Protection According to of the Data Code, personal data not be without the of the data However, provides an and that if the data are made public by the data they can be without the data it can be that doxing cases be under the Data since cyberbullies use data that have been made public by the data In personal data may only be in with the and of the Data and other In other words, of personal data that the of the Data would be is not to that an individual publishes information about themselves that it can be used against for malicious purposes. if the data publishes personal data with some of the to that data should be To this people can publish their information, such as their home address, phone number, or address on their in order to potential to an of they are and with The that the data have been made public by the data should not give people the right to or publish the data for malicious purposes. The information be used for purpose other According to the Data Protection the that data can be by others does not always that the data are However, the term has a within the of the Data and is directly to the purpose for which the data made the information the contact information published by a person her on a can only be used for the purpose of the or information about this it for other as should be this of of the be an tool to doxing In EU data privacy law, the definition of made public by the data is in of the provides an which personal data may be without if it to personal data that are made public by the data However, it is to that even if the data are publicly the in of the and a to be such data that are publicly The Data Protection that personal data to information to an or whether or not the information is to the the that such data have been made publicly available does not it from the data protection law and its publicly available information be under the without other and be an individual on social it is that they it to be by a wide However, that does not that can collect and use the data for malicious The collection and use of personal information from social media should be directly to the the information was made publicly available for which no is to As a even if the data are made public by the data they be used to the data under the purpose limitation of the the of also has a and the of data for illegal and data privacy law the purpose limitation principle in of the According to the the that someone information on social media without does not to use it for other In other words, the that data are publicly does not that has the right to use it for does it that the individual the data has their to as made is not in the Data Protection Act However, it can be that the data should the data to a of people are not always to be In being able to information does not that it can be used for for it is not public data if number in the of a on social media or if someone their address with their on a the use of data made public by the data in order to people is under data privacy law as In law, there is no data protection legislation. the the Act the to bring to against or and to privacy and data protection The that purpose and use means data collection to that which is with the of a particular or a with the or as or by In other words, under the purpose should the purpose or for which personal information is to be On the other hand, use limitation to personal information that should be used for the purpose in the The of personal information should be for a purpose with the purpose for which it was On this it is to that some the purpose limitation in data As a to the even if the data used are made public by the data personal information with malicious intent will these the for provides no purpose or data some may to the purpose limitation in their to the use of public data for doxing. it can be that data privacy law personal data for malicious purposes, and of whether the data are made public or it be used to people under the purpose limitation principle. may private information about themselves online, but all of the information that is in data requires a Internet with malicious intent use doxing as a tool by personal information, which is in this cyber more and cyberbullies often use personal data as a to cause and to their violating their can be that doxing involves more the right to Doxing has the potential to not only the right to but also the right to the right to physical the right to the right to as as in to doxing, the legally protected should more The right to and and and it be the legally protected by individual has the right to and or her by or her and in a without being in a psychological and be that people are to doxing will be able to their and In the doxing and they be able to a Doxing is a that more data future should that all of the to be this it is to on the of malicious intent and on such as whether the data are public or whether the of the data is in doxing The of has made personal information online with malicious purpose a to use doxing as a tool to or or even their While various cybercrime have been enacted in to the of cyber the issue of doxing has not received Doxing involves and personal which is data under data privacy personal data can only be with from the data and under However, cyberbullies often that they use data that have been published by the data that they to of the data to the this article revealed that the purpose limitation principle the use of personal information for doxing, of whether the information is publicly or This article that the existing criminal approaches in the EU and are for doxing its is and are and they may not all of this the that doxing to individual privacy and it is to legal Hong has an in this by directly and doxing into its legal In the EU, people can to have sensitive information to removed from the Internet under the This be to doxing. However, to be only when information is or and it be against other such as the right to this the form of the right to be may not address doxing. On the other hand, Germany the Act in In the the social media that have million or more users in Germany to remove content that is within 24 a doxing is not directly under law, be to doxing cases including hate or fake which are However, doxing does not always hate or fake news, which are the types of content that However, the purpose limitation which is a of data privacy law, the collection and disclosure of data for malicious purposes. As the data privacy law provides the legal framework to combat doxing, countries have not on doxing. since doxing is a multifaceted that not their there is a for a comprehensive that directly and doxing, on data privacy future should that doxing may many other from the right to doxing is for individuals to and their and the of the approaches which may a of to the new should the definition of doxing to a or a of This would for a more comprehensive to combat doxing, as individuals in this may not always a of that can be or in intent is a that distinguishes doxing from and new should for it in The use of to search or an sensitive information can be in malicious intent and doxers for their including such can a the of privacy and of without causing to On the other hand, social media platforms have a in preventing doxing, that many on these media platforms should and to their users against doxing. should and guidelines to that personal information is such as and can be utilized to identify and remove doxing content
Source: International Data Privacy Law
DOI: 10.1093/idpl/ipad011
Author: Batuhan Kukul
Institution: Bahçeşehir University
Language: English
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,251
OpenAlex ID: W4382753549
