Work

Kathleen M. Brown Undoing Slavery. Bodies, Race, and Rights in the Age of Abolition. University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia (PA) 2023. 446 pp. $39.95.

Year: 2023
Type: book-review
Abstract: How could the body not be central to histories of slavery?And yet, in her latest book on the abolitionist struggle in Pennsylvania and Virginia in the first half of the nineteenth century, Kathleen M. Brown argues that the body as an analytical category can be used to enlighten many more aspects of the discourse and daily practices of abolitionists, as well as the lawsuits held in this period fighting over the rights to freedom of enslaved men and women.Brown has written a comprehensive social, legal, economic, and medical history of the age of abolition, based on an extraordinary number of primary and secondary sources.This well-documented, readable, and multifaceted book aims to revisit the well-known fight against slavery and racism in the United States through the lens of the concept of "embodied self-sovereignty".This "bodycentered approach" (p.7) to the abolition movement includes consideration of the major theme of birthright, the frequent mentioning of the body by abolitionists in regard to slavery's physical violence, the physical effects of their exhausting activism and resistance, their healing practices, and overall the centrality of well-being and bodily integrity to a genuine exercise of rights.But this perspective also entails making connections with contemporary medical theories on blood and the racialized body.These informative links reveal how medicine and racism were inextricably entangled, and how they impacted on the metaphors used by abolitionists and on the ideas presented by "expert" witnesses in court cases revolving around race and the identification of enslaved people who had escaped.The ultimate aim of this approach, Brown contends, is to argue against human rights scholarship that has neglected the body and focused only on the legal recognition of universal rights.Instead, the author aims to highlight the importance of the domestic and the intimate, such as family integrity, corporeal care, and the right to move freely, as necessary conditions for achieving these human rights, not as secondary aims to be fought for after securing these rights.Although the choice of focusing on the body "on its own terms" (p.4) and seeing the human body as having "its own stubborn logic" (p. 6) could have deserved more theoretical embedding (for instance, to explain whether the body is referred to in a discursive or more phenomenological way), overall this approach leads to a multilayered and humane history featuring Black and white abolitionists, including men and women, such as Frederick Douglass, Richard Allen, and Sarah Mapps Douglass, but also doctors embracing increasingly racist ideas.The narrative pays
Institution: Utrecht University
Language: English
Subfield: History
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4384068240
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 10