Work

Editorial

Year: 2023
Type: editorial
Abstract: Evaluators paying renewed attention to implementation was a feature of the previous issue of Evaluation published in April of this year.Several articles in this issue also highlight the importance of implementation in support of both policy effectiveness and policy development.Not yet a trend, but striking nonetheless. . .The opening article starts from the observation that global health policy lacks the kinds of theoretical underpinnings needed to improve implementation and 'inform strategies that aim at social change'.The authors -Sara Van Belle, Ibukun-Oluwa Abejirinde, Aloysius Ssennyonjo, Prashanth Srinivas, Pragati Hebbar and Bruno Marchal -write from a realist perspective.Their 'starting point is that programme evaluations often fail to indicate why and how a programme works, and how and in which context conditions it could be scaled up successfully elsewhere'.This is a theoretical challenge which realism, with its focus on theory building and theory testing, is well suited to take on.The authors' central argument is that Margaret Archer's 'Structure-Agency-Culture' (SAC) framework illuminates 'how a programme is embedded in its context and how the interaction between the programme and the context shapes the outcomes'.Much of the article is devoted to examining 'how the SAC framework can help in eliciting initial programme theories'.Van Belle and colleagues illustrate this with a worked example of an adolescent reproductive health study, offering a 'four-step framework' to integrate SAC with 'the logic of evaluation'.The next three articles also have something to say about implementation.This is situated in evaluations of crime, social disorder and violence: knife crime in England and Wales, youth violence in Jamaica and the Caribbean and settings characterised by violence in international conflict settings.Laura Caulfield, Zara Quigg, Nicole Adams-Quackenbush and Hannah Timpson reflect on the early stages of an evaluation of 4 out of 18 Violence Reduction Units (VRUs) in England and Wales.These Units, set up following a major increase in knife crime in the United Kingdom in 2019, are multi-agency and place-based.They follow a public health approach to violence reduction, in line with World Health Organization recommendations.VRUs are understood in 'systemic' terms, framed by a 'socioecological framework' that distinguishes the causes of violence at individual, family, community and societal levels.The evaluation design as outlined by Caulfield and colleagues faced similar choices to other complex, placebased multi-agency policies.For example, readers familiar with European Union (EU) Structural Fund evaluations will recognise the challenge of evaluating interventions that are not isolatable, making it 'difficult to ascertain whether changes to regional violence are a direct result of the VRU activities, or whether there are other factors at play'.The design described by the authors is concerned with implementation and process as well as impacts.
Source: Evaluation
Author: Elliot Stern
Language: Spanish
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4385881484
Cites: 2
Cited by: 1
Related to: