Work

Borderline consciousness, when it’s neither determinately true nor determinately false that experience is present

Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: This article defends the existence of borderline consciousness. In borderline consciousness, conscious experience is neither determinately present nor determinately absent, but rather somewhere between. The argument in brief is this. In considering what types of systems are conscious, we face a quadrilemma. Either nothing is conscious, or everything is conscious, or there’s a sharp boundary across the apparent continuum between conscious systems and nonconscious ones, or consciousness is a vague property admitting indeterminate cases. Assuming mainstream naturalism about consciousness, we ought to reject the first three options, which forces us to the fourth, indeterminacy. Standard objections to the existence of borderline consciousness turn on the inconceivability of borderline cases. However, borderline cases are only inconceivable by an inappropriately demanding standard of conceivability. I conclude with some plausible cases and applications.
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $2,890
OpenAlex ID: W4387335257
FWCI: 46.67
Cites: 66
Cited by: 72
Related to: 10