Work

Sleep, Circadian Rhythms, and Aging: Advancing Knowledge to Promote Older Adults’ Health

Year: 2023
Type: article
Abstract: The prevalence of sleep and circadian rhythm disturbances increases with advancing age. In addition to being common clinical complaints, problems with sleep and sleep–wake patterns are increasingly recognized as risk factors for poor health outcomes. Various treatments are also available for sleep–wake disturbances, making them potentially modifiable risk factors for those outcomes. In this special issue of The Journals of Gerontology: Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences, we present results from 13 recent studies investigating links of sleep or circadian rhythms with cognition, pain, and multimorbidity, and examining aging-related changes in sleep and their predictors. Three articles in this issue examined prospective associations of sleep or circadian characteristics with cognitive outcomes. In a prospective analysis of data from the Boston Puerto Rican Health Study, Arevalo et al. investigated associations of self-reported sleep duration and insomnia symptoms with 10-year changes in cognition (1). At baseline, participants with short and long sleep duration had poorer global cognition and executive function, but insomnia symptoms were unassociated with cognitive performance. Longitudinally, there were significant interactions with age and sex; associations of short and long sleep with cognitive decline were stronger among older men, compared to younger men and women. Similarly, associations of insomnia symptoms with memory decline were strongest in older men. Findings underscore the importance of considering the heterogeneity of associations of sleep and cognitive outcomes across population subgroups. Qi et al. examined insomnia symptoms as a mediator of the link between social isolation and 8-year cognitive decline in nearly 6 000 dementia-free Health and Retirement Study (HRS) participants aged 50+ (2). They observed significant longitudinal bidirectional associations between social isolation and cognition, and insomnia at Year 4 partially mediated the effect of social isolation at baseline on cognitive functioning at Year 8, explaining 6.2% of the total effect. Promoting social engagement and addressing sleep problems in middle-aged and older adults who are socially isolated may help slow the decline in cognitive function with aging. Diurnal patterns of light exposure affect circadian rhythms and related sleep–wake cycles. Blackwell et al. examined prospective associations of 24-hour patterns of light and activity with global cognition and executive function over 4.2 years in >1 000 older men in the Osteoporotic Fractures in Men Study (MrOS) (3). Light and activity data were gathered objectively using actigraphs with light sensors for an average of 5 days. Older men with smaller phasor magnitude (ie, poorer alignment of light and activity patterns) had significantly lower executive function cross-sectionally, and a more rapid decline in executive function over time compared to those with larger phasor magnitude. Findings beg the question of whether interventions to improve alignment of light and activity patterns may slow cognitive decline. This collection also includes 2 review articles focused on sleep–wake and cognitive outcomes. Carlson et al. performed a narrative review on sleep and circadian rhythms in relation to episodic memory in older adults (4). Episodic memory, a form of conscious memory for events grounded in a specific time and place, is known to decline with advancing age. Findings included associations of sleep duration with episodic memory, with both short and long (vs intermediate) sleep linked with worse performance. Disrupted circadian activity rhythms have also been linked with cognitive outcomes. The authors noted that studies exploring the potential interactive effects of sleep and circadian disruption on episodic memory are lacking, highlighting the potential importance of a multidimensional perspective on sleep and circadian health. A systematic review by Li and colleagues summarized 23 observational and 12 intervention studies on daytime napping and cognitive health in older adults (5). Findings from both cross-sectional and longitudinal observational studies suggested a potential U-shaped relationship between napping duration and cognition, with short/moderate-duration naps linked to better cognition relative to non-napping or longer naps. Most, but not all intervention studies showed the benefits of a single session of afternoon napping for psychomotor function and working memory. The authors indicated a need for future observational studies with both subjective and objective assessment of napping; consideration of the timing, duration, frequency, and intentionality of daytime napping; and identification of the causes of daytime napping. They suggested intervention studies should explore both short- and long-term effects of napping habits on cognitive health. Finally, numerous studies have linked sleep-disordered breathing (SDB; eg, obstructive sleep apnea) to poor cognitive outcomes. Continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) therapy is a well-established treatment for SDB, but CPAP adherence is problematic. Predictors of CPAP adherence in persons with mild cognitive impairment (MCI), whose SDB may in fact be contributing to cognitive deficits, are poorly understood. In this issue, Richards et al. examined predictors of CPAP adherence among 174 participants with MCI (6). Although overall 3-month adherence was relatively high (~74%), they found a remarkable 10-fold greater odds of adherence among White compared to Black participants. Given the elevated prevalence of both dementia and SDB among minoritized communities, including Black populations, initiatives to enhance adherence may help increase health equity. Three papers in this issue address links among sleep, pain, and health. Zhou et al. examined prospective associations of self-reported nighttime sleep and daytime nap duration, sleep quality, and interactions among these sleep parameters, with progression of multimorbidity in approximately 9 000 adults aged 45+ followed every 2–3 years in the China Health and Retirement Longitudinal Study (CHARLS) (7). Compared to those sleeping 7–8 hours per night, those sleeping ≤5 hours or 5–7 hours had a greater risk of progression of multimorbidity, and those sleeping ≤5 hours had greater odds of not just one, but an increasing number of chronic conditions (from 1 to 4+ new conditions) over time. Similar associations were observed for total sleep duration (nighttime + nap duration), but not nap duration alone. Participants reporting restless sleep at least once per week had a greater risk of progression of multimorbidity and a greater odds of an increasing number of conditions over time. Notably, there were interactions of nighttime and total sleep duration with restless sleep on risk of multimorbidity; in general, associations were strongest among those with both shorter sleep duration and poor sleep quality. There was some evidence of stronger associations among female participants and those under age 65, providing another example of subgroup differences in sleep–health associations. Sheffler et al. investigated cross-sectional associations of pain and anxiety with sleep quality, measured by an item from the Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, and examined moderation of these associations by self-reported physical activity in 281 community-dwelling older adults residing in Florida who completed an online survey (8). Anxiety and pain each were independently associated with poorer sleep quality, after accounting for several covariates, including physical activity. Pain was also indirectly associated with poorer sleep quality through anxiety symptoms. The authors also found that, among participants reporting high levels of physical activity, greater anxiety was not associated with poorer self-rated sleep quality. Like the findings of Qi et al. (2), results highlight the potential for both direct and indirect effects linking sleep with health outcomes in older adults. Lucke et al. conducted a 7-day ecological momentary assessment study investigating temporal associations among self-reported sleep quality and duration, pain, and self-rated health in 170 young–old and old–old German adults (9). Dynamic structural equation modeling revealed that better-than-usual sleep quality was followed by better pain and health ratings the next day, and better-than-usual health ratings were followed by better sleep quality the next night. There were no significant associations of sleep duration with self-rated health or pain. This issue also contains 4 studies examining links between aging and sleep. There are widely acknowledged age-related changes in sleep. For example, with age, sleep tends to become shorter and more fragmented, and less time is spent in slow-wave and rapid eye movement sleep (10). Using data from the HRS, Chen examined longitudinal change in insomnia symptoms between 2002 and 2018 and evaluated mechanisms that may explain these trajectories across racial/ethnic groups (11). They also studied the effect of age cohorts on these associations. Insomnia severity increased with age, with greater changes among minoritized groups. Adjusting for health characteristics (eg, chronic conditions) and social factors (eg, employment status) markedly reduced age-related changes in insomnia symptoms among White participants. In minoritized groups, however, changes in insomnia symptoms remained after adjustment. Additionally, significant age-cohort effects on insomnia symptom trajectories were observed among race/ethnic groups. Associations of sleep disturbance and health may differ between younger and older age groups for various reasons, including different environmental and health contexts. Gibson et al. used data from New Zealand to compare atypical sleep duration (short or long vs typical) between younger (<65 years) and older (≥65 years) adults, and assessed associations of sleep duration with health and lifestyle factors within each group (12). Overall, results showed that long sleep duration was more prevalent in older than younger groups, whereas short sleep was more common in younger versus older groups. Further, atypical sleep duration was linked to various unfavorable lifestyle and health factors in both age categories, although these associations were less pronounced in the older age group. Relatively little is known about the effect of childhood experiences on sleep in later life. Sheffler et al. examined the extent to which adverse childhood experiences (ACEs) were associated with self-reported sleep quality in older adulthood and evaluated whether this association differed as a function of emotion regulation strategies participants endorsed (13). A greater number of ACEs was associated with poorer sleep quality in later life, but this association was reduced in individuals who used the emotion regulation strategies of positive reappraisal and refocusing on planning. There has been considerable attention in recent years to links between the gut microbiome and health, but sleep has been understudied, particularly in the context of aging. The gut microbiome is the composition of microorganisms present in the gut. Estaki et al. examined associations of subjective and objective sleep and circadian factors with the gut microbiome using data from MrOS (14). They found that, in general, better self-reported sleep quality was associated with greater alpha diversity (diversity of species within an individual), and more consistent circadian patterns were associated with greater beta diversity (differences in microbiota between individuals). These sleep–wake characteristics were also associated with specific microbial taxa known to be linked with better overall health. Together, the studies in this special issue shed light on the complex links of sleep and circadian factors with aging-related health outcomes. Specifically, results expand the evidence supporting links between sleep/circadian factors and cognition, pain, and multimorbidity in older adults. A recurring theme is the importance of considering interactions, or subgroup effects in the context of sleep and aging. For example, studies identified differences in sleep and associated aging-related outcomes by age or age cohort (1,7,11,12), sex (1,7,9), and race/ethnicity (6,11). The studies also demonstrated interactions between different sleep characteristics (duration and quality) with respect to health outcomes (7), as well as beneficial moderating effects of lifestyle factors (physical activity) (8) and emotion regulation strategies which can help buffer the effects of anxiety or ACEs on sleep (13). In addition, two studies tested mediation effects involving sleep. Qi et al found that insomnia symptoms partially mediated the effects of social isolation on subsequent cognitive outcomes (2), whereas Sheffler et al. found that the effects of pain on sleep quality may be mediated by anxiety (8). A variety of sleep and circadian characteristics are represented in the included studies, highlighting the importance of considering a multidimensional sleep health perspective in older adults. Several studies underscore the importance of circadian rhythms or daytime napping, which can affect sleep–wake rhythms, in relation to outcomes (3–5). Other studies focus on sleep disorders such as SDB (6) or insomnia symptoms (1,2,11). Overall, the results presented in this special issue help further our understanding of the complex associations of sleep and circadian health with other age-related conditions, and the factors that drive sleep changes with age. They also demonstrate associations of an intermediate sleep duration (approximately 7–8 hours) with better health outcomes. There were some important limitations to several of the studies, however, that must be considered. For example, the cross-sectional designs of some studies—all of which were also observational—limit our ability to evaluate temporal links between predictors and outcomes. Observational studies cannot demonstrate definitive causal associations, and longitudinal designs help establish the potential for a causal link. In addition, there are many factors, such as psychological variables (eg, anxiety), medications, comorbidities, and environmental factors (eg, ambient temperature) that may influence sleep but were not consistently included in analyses. Further longitudinal research and sleep-targeting intervention trials with multidimensional self-report and objective sleep measures are needed to better understand the potential causal effects of sleep on important aging-related outcomes and the extent to which promoting sleep health may prevent poor outcomes and optimize health among older people. None. A.P.S. received payment for serving as a consultant for Merck, received honoraria from Springer Nature Switzerland AG for guest editing special issues of Current Sleep Medicine Reports, and is a paid consultant to Sequoia Neurovitality. The other authors declare no conflict.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4387472288
FWCI: 1.456
Cites: 14
Cited by: 8
Related to: 10