Work

The Procedure and Limits of Reimbursement of the Amounts Paid for Professional Legal Assistance in Criminal Proceedings

Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: Introduction: the constitutional right of citizens to receive professional legal assistance can be secured if there is an effective and affordable mechanism for reimbursing expenses related to legal assistance from an attorney. The insufficient scientific research on the topic as well as not always effective reforms of the institutions of reimbursing expenses for the attorney’s assistance to rehabilitated persons and to victims, the collection from the convict of procedural costs related to the renumeration of the appointed attorney, result in judicial errors when resolving issues of reimbursement of such expenses, which, in turn, leads to violation of the rights of participants in the criminal process. The purpose of the study is, first, to identify the legal nature, the most effective procedural form, and fair limits of reimbursement for legal assistance received by: a rehabilitated person, a person unreasonably prosecuted in a criminal case of private prosecution, a victim – on a reimbursable basis (under an agreement with an attorney) as well as by the suspect or the accused having no possibility to hire an attorney – on a non-reimbursable basis (with funding from the federal budget); second, to formulate proposals for further improvement of the institution of procedural costs reimbursement. Results: we analyzed the development dynamics of criminal procedure legislation and the impact that the positions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation and law application practice have on this development. The analysis revealed some shortcomings in law and the practice of its application, solutions to these problems are proposed. Conclusions: we defined the criteria for determining the limits of reimbursement of expenses incurred by a person subjected to unlawful or unfounded criminal prosecution; formulated a list of grounds for exempting the accused from procedural costs being collected from him for an appointed attorney in cases where such expenses were unreasonable and (or) irrational; described the way to further improve the procedure for reimbursing the victim for the assistance of an attorney that would allow ensuring equal procedural opportunities for victims in terms of reimbursement of expenses incurred both in pre-trial proceedings and in trial.
Authors: I. V. Kilina, N. M. Kipnis
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W4403471035
FWCI: 2.273
Cites:
Cited by: 3
Related to: 10