The Impact of Climate Change on Rural Livelihoods in South Asia: A Comparative Study of India, Nepal, and Bangladesh
Year: 2024
Type: preprint
Abstract: The Impact of Climate Change on Rural Livelihoods in South Asia: A Comparative Study of India, Nepal, and Bangladesh AbstractThis article provides a comparative assessment of several aspects of climate change on rural livelihoods. In India, Nepal and Bangladesh have fairly large commonalities in terms of climate risk as with many South Asian countries, all three nations showcased stark differences in contextual geographical and governance contexts. However, they are all extremely vulnerable to the risks of climate change because of their inherent reliance on agrarian economies, fragile ecological contexts and adaptive capacity in rural contexts. In addressing these issues, the assessment harnesses climate data, socio-economic variables and responses from field work to articulate how changes in precipitation patterns due to climate change, glacial melt, increases in heat-stress, and salinisation are affecting the rural economy, and consequently impacting the forms and cycles of poverty, and have resulted in a destabilisation of social structures. Finally, the paper reflects on government level policies, the importance of local adaptation and households, and the role of international development assistance. By positioning the similarities and distinctions pertinent to three countries, we are able to contribute to understanding climate resilience and rural vulnerability in South Asia, and make strategic and policy recommendations to integrate climate action. IntroductionClimate change has become a challenge not only for the environment, but as a significant socio-political issue, particularly for the Global South. South Asia, which has more than 1.8 billion people, is among the most vulnerable regions to climate. Much of the rural population in the Global South, especially in South Asia, face a high climate risk because they depend on climate sensitive activities (such as agriculture, fisheries, and forestry). The need for context-specific adaptation is evident when considering that in South Asia, the rural population, which is the most vulnerable to climate, presents as diverse as India’s drought-prone areas, Nepal’s glacial-fed farmlands, and Bangladesh’s salinity-affected deltas.This paper explores the uneven impacts of climate change on rural livelihoods in India, Nepal, and Bangladesh. Beyond identifying biophysical stressors, it will examine how the existing socio-economic systems mediate or amplify climate risk. The objectives of this paper are informed by interdisciplinary approaches in the fields of environmental studies, development economics, and climate justice. It is important to consider how biophysical impacts are socially or culturally constrained, and rural adaptation or resilience must work through the social context. This approach critically examines not only the technical adequacy of national and local initiatives, but the extent to which they emerge from a legible social reality. It will conclude by making recommendations for action towards more sustainable adaptation, participatory policy development, and regional collaboration. Climate Change and Rural Livelihoods in IndiaAgricultural Disruption and Hydrological InsecurityIndia's climate vulnerability is acute but heterogeneous. The monsoon system that brings over 70% of the average annual rainfall has become increasingly erratic from climate change. According to studies by the Indian Ministry of Earth Sciences (2020), average temperatures have steered upward with little indication of any downturn — around 0.7°C\2010 since 1901 — and heat waves more common, with the reliability of seasonal rainfall in decline. These climate changes have serious ramifications for rural livelihoods with over 50% of the population still directly or indirectly engaged in the agricultural sector. Rainfed agricultural production is already severely limited under climate change conditions, and significant reductions in groundwater resources - especially in the semi-arid regions of Maharashtra, Gujarat and Rajasthan - streamlines the dual crisis of unsustainable economic practice and resource scarcity. With the lower classes of smallholder farmers spending every available dollar and then exhausting what little credit resources available to them, a group of subpopulations that represents the backbone of the agrarian economy of India, is severely impacted by climate change-induced vulnerabilities, partly due to excess financial resource limitations, overall lack of technology-based initiatives supporting natural climate protection, and institutional resource support for plummeting rainfall resources. While disadvantages faced by smallholder farmers were once offset through seasonal planning and knowledge of water-maintaining pest deterrents and soil management practices, crop failures are on the rise and risk-reducing strategies are becoming ineffective. Due to low cost risk-sharing models and crop risk denials, structural changes in agrarian distress are becoming an operational feature of the rural operational reality.Socioeconomic and Gendered RepercussionsThe economic effects of climate change stress are alarming. The Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations (2019) state that climate variability could result in declines in agricultural incomes of more than 25% in the coming decades. This has led to an increase in rural indebtedness, food insecurity, and a trend of distress migration by rural populations, particularly among youth. The distress migration, when men labour migrate to urban destinations for employment, is clear evidence of the growing feminization of agriculture; women are being left to manage household food security and agricultural land, without the rights and/or institutional support of ownership or land management.And, as climate disruption increases, this fragmentation is fueled in rural areas by the inability to draw upon customary, kin-based, or caste-based support networks, the resilience and longevity of which are being eroded by climate-induced changes in rural economy uncertainty.In this regard, climate change is more than a biophysical phenomenon; it is a relentless force that changes rural society by undermining the customary ways of living and the structures and institutions of piloting rural social and economic life. Climate Change and Rural Livelihoods in NepalGlacial Retreat and Hydro-Agricultural SystemsNepal's unique ecology—steep mountains, fragile ecosystems, and widespread rural settlements—means it is particularly vulnerable to the hydrology impacts of climate change. The Himalayas, the source of meltwater for agriculture and hydropower, are retreating like never before. The Himalayan Monitoring Report (2020) states that, over the last thirty years, Nepal has lost about 25% of its glacier volume. This loss puts downstream irrigation at risk, in addition to the possibility of events such as glacial lake outburst floods (GLOFs), which disproportionately impacts rural and isolated smallholder farmers.In terms of agriculture, the situation is dire. Traditional cropping systems are collapsing as water from glacial-fed water becomes increasingly unreliable. Many of the mid-hill and Terai farmers are practising a desperate version of subsistence food production that is done with limited support from the state as they are being forced to navigate a water regime that is increasingly unreliable. The situation is compounded by underinvestment in rural public goods, limited hydrological data, and ineffective governance and accountability mechanisms.Adaptive Strategies and Structural ConstraintsDespite this, some community-level initiatives are beginning to emerge. Agroforestry projects and some climate resilient cash crops (like cardamom and coffee) are taking place in several areas. Community based organisations (CBOs), cooperatives and community groups are experimenting with different water harvesting techniques and participatory approaches in watershed management. While certainly encouraging, however, interventions are still small-scale, under-resourced, and relatively irregular.Structural constraints also limit Nepal's adaptive capacity, especially low public sector investment into agricultural R&D, poorly resourced extension services, and limited opportunities for microfinance in rural areas. Without ongoing institutional support from, and at the same time sustainable partnering with local communities in, the central government and international community, local level innovations will ultimately have little remaining impact and will not fulfil their potential: developmental marginalisation coupled with environmental vulnerability creates a particularly distinct obstacle to sustainable rural resilience. Climate Change and Rural Livelihoods in BangladeshCoastal Fragility and Agricultural CollapseBangladesh is often cited as the global epicenter of climate vulnerability due to its low elevation and high population density, and the threat of sea-level rise, cyclones, and increasing salinity. Approximately 60% of the population are rural. Agriculture provides subsistence and employment for millions of Bangladeshis, and climate adaptation on coastal agricultural lands is critical. The increasing salinization of agricultural crops in coastal areas is a result of ascending sea-level rise - exacerbated by tidal surges from cyclones - and ruining farmland and thus livelihoods.According to the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN, 2020), over 20% of coastal agricultural land in Bangladesh is saline with cascading declines in crops, freshwater, and ecosystem health. Hence, increasing saline agricultural land and increasingly frequent storms, such as Cyclone Amphan (2020), has destabilized rural livelihoods. For example, the southwestern districts of Satkhira and Khulna will suffer chronic inundation and forced displacement as a result of increased salinization, reduced crop yield, and cyclones.Institutional Responses and Grassroots InnovationIn spite of substantial barriers, Bangladesh has a well-respected and recognised adaptation approach globally. There is the National Adaptation Programme of Action (NAPA) and subsequent broader programmes (like the Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy & Action Plan - BCCSAP) in which adaptation has primarily focused on improving (for example cyclone shelters and engineering works - embankments), salinity tolerant crops and disaster risk reduction through prediction and prevention.At the local level, there have been examples of genuine creative adaptation. Farmers are using "floating gardens" (baira), made of water hyacinth and bamboo to grow vegetables, an ingenious way of producing crops in inundated areas. NGOs like BRAC and Practical Action have introduced training on: integrated farming systems; rainwater harvesting; and climate resilient housing. These new practices are being introduced on a large scale, but cannot be scaled because of poverty traps, bureaucratic inertia and upstream funding for downstream actors. Comparative Analysis: Shared Vulnerabilities, Divergent ContextsCommon Patterns of Rural Climate RiskA range of interconnected vulnerabilities can be noted across India, Nepal and Bangladesh. First, the rural economy is heavily reliant on agricultural production, which is naturally sensitive to the impacts of climate change and has established a very precarious economic base. Second, the water available in these areas will either be reduced in availability and quality (i.e. in rain, glacial melt or groundwater), or uncertain. Third, with inadequate rural infrastructure and limited access to climate information systems, insurance or credit, the exposures can increase while recoverability is decreased.Socially, all three countries are experiencing growing climate-induced displacement, feminization of agricultural labor, and decline of traditional knowledge systems that had historically served as buffer systems against environmental stress. Culture and institutional context may differ across the three areas, but they largely appear on a shared trajectory toward growing insecurity and social dislocation.Country-Specific Variations and Structural ImplicationsStill, significant variation exists. Owing to its geographic expanse and institutional capacity, India has created quite complete meteorological networks and adaptation programs; however, these have been inequitably distributed and usually inaccessible to marginalized populations. The federal system of governance also results in significant regional variation of policy implementation.With its mountain ecology and infrastructural deficits, Nepal’s capacity for physical access and service delivery is a continuing predicament. Its community-based adaptation programming—while effective at the local level—needs greater alignment with national priorities and transboundary hydrological management.Despite persistent susceptibility to extreme weather events, Bangladesh has built a culture of disaster preparedness and international engagement. However, challenges remain, as a country defined by a dense population is under an abundance of demographic pressure, much land is essential for adaptation which is unavailable, and poverty levels restrict possibilities for adaptation within already damaged coastal areas.Regional Dynamics and the Case for Integrated ResponsesClimate change does not acknowledge national borders in South Asia. The interconnectedness of river basins, migratory pathways, and shared ecological systems obliges forms of cooperation that include data sharing, early warning systems, and adaptation funding. The South Asia Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) has identified climate cooperation in name only, as overwhelming climate adjustments we see already and for the future continue to occur. The urgency of a reinvigorated regional climate compact that is guided by mutual accountability, ecological justice, and common technological progress cannot be overstated. Conclusion: Toward a Just and Resilient Rural FutureThe evidence in India, Nepal and Bangladesh presents uncomfortable truths. Climate change is not a threat looming on the horizon; it is now a catastrophic reality for rural peoples in South Asia. As the comparative reflection suggests, the intertwining of environmental degradation and economic precarity, against a backdrop of weak institutional response, creates long-term disempowerment for rural populations.At the same time, these realities also open a door to transformative policy. Climate adaptation cannot be merely a technocratic exercise; it must be socially embedded, equity focused, and participatory. Governments should acknowledge rural realities, and ensure that smallholder farmers and marginalised rural groups are prioritised in climate action plans, are included, where possible, in new climate-smart technologies and are financially enabled, where necessary, to contribute to climate action.At a more international level, multilateral development banks, climate funds, and bilateral donor agencies must invest in new funding streams designed to support locally-led adaptation actions, while establishing good practice in cross-border knowledge sharing (for example, in water governance and agroecological innovations). Additionally, renewed regional action plans must be established, passing from an over-focus on symbolic and rhetorical commitments to protocols that map and model our shared ecologies (and different historical responsibilities).Ultimately, securing rural livelihoods in South Asia during the climate crisis cannot solely be reliant upon scientific innovation and financial investment, but instead requires a reimagining of development itself – where ecological stewardship, social dignity and rural agency is at its heart. References ・Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations. (2019). Climate change and rural incomes: Challenges for India’s smallholder farmers. Retrieved from https://icrier.org/・International Union for Conservation of Nature. (2020). Salinity and climate impacts on agriculture in Bangladesh. Retrieved from https://www.iucn.org/・Ministry of Earth Sciences, Government of India. (2020). Assessment of climate change over the Indian region: A report of the Ministry of Earth Sciences (MoES), Government of India. New Delhi: MoES. https://moes.gov.in・Himalayan Monitoring Report. (2020). The state of Himalayan glaciers: Implications for water resources in Nepal. Kathmandu: ICIMOD. https://icimod.org・Bangladesh Ministry of Environment and Forests. (2009). Bangladesh Climate Change Strategy and Action Plan (BCCSAP). Dhaka: Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh.・Practical Action. (2018). Floating gardens in Bangladesh: Adaptation for resilience. Retrieved from https://practicalaction.org/・SAARC Secretariat. (2022). Regional cooperation on climate change: Status and prospects. Kathmandu: South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation.
Author: Shunsuke Sato
Language: English
Subfield: Agronomy and Crop Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Keywords: climate change impacts, rural livelihoods, climate change vulnerability, climate resilience, climate change adaptation, rainfall variability, glacier melt, heat stress, salinization, poverty, rural poverty, climate policy, local adaptation, development aid, India, Nepal, Bangladesh, South Asia, climate justice, agricultural dependence, climate governance, participatory adaptation
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4403718610
