BN SO29 - Overinvestigation and unnecessary surgery for Gallbladder Polyps: An audit of compliance with ESGAR guidelines
Year: 2024
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Background Incidental gallbladder polyps are increasingly reported on abdominal ultrasound and have a theoretical association with increased risk of gallbladder cancer. Most gallbladder polyps are actually gallstones and there is little evidence for any survival benefit or reduced rates of gallbladder cancer in patients under ultrasound surveillance. ESGAR guidelines attempt to standardize and rationalize surveillance protocols, balancing the risks of missed early cancers versus the costs of surveillance investigations. This audit aims to assess the investigation and management of gallbladder polyps as per ESGAR guidelines at a single NHS trust. Method An audit was conducted at a single NHS Trust in England. Searches were conducted on the electronic patient record for patients coded for K82.8 (Gallbladder pathology: other) from 01/01/2022 to 31/12/2023. Patient records were examined for radiological imaging confirming diagnosis of gallbladder polyp. Data was analysed using Microsoft excel and compared with the 2021 ESGAR guidance on management of gallbladder polyps. Results 97 patients were included. All polyps were diagnosed with abdominal ultrasound. Patients had, on average, two ultrasounds. 51% were seen in outpatients clinic. 35 patients (36%) underwent laparoscopic cholecystectomy (including all patients with a polyp >10mm). Histology confirmed diagnosis of cholecystitis (69%), pseudopolyp (9%), gallbladder polyp (6%) and IPMN (3%). 74% (26/35) of patients that underwent cholecystectomy had biliary symptoms and 77% (20/26) had cholecystitis confirmed by histology. Despite having biliary symptoms at first assessment, 47% of polyp patients went on to have two ultrasounds and two clinic appointments. Conclusion The study confirms that the majority of ultrasound detected polyps are not neoplastic, and patients undergo multiple hospital visits, incurring significant non-therapeutic costs. Adherence to ESGAR guidelines is inconsistent. In the symptomatic cohort, however, a low threshold for laparoscopic cholecystectomy should be considered given the high likelihood of underlying stones.
Source: British journal of surgery
Authors: Jessie Blackburn, Nicholas Farksas, Fiona Crotty, Freya Miller, Ajay Belgaumkar
Institution: East Surrey Hospital
Language: English
Subfield: Pulmonary and Respiratory Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4404282539