A unifying theory for the evaluation of conditional Akaike information for mixed-effects models
Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: {Simulation studies are conducted to assess the accuracy of our method for evaluating the conditional AIC and its model selection performance across a wide range of mixed-effects models. The proposed approach provides a valuable tool for model selection in the context of mixed-effects modelling.} We propose two methods to evaluate the conditional Akaike information (cAI) for mixed-effects models with no restriction on cluster size. Method 1 is designed for continuous data and includes formulae for the derivatives of fixed and random effects estimators with respect to observations. Method 2, compatible with any type of observation, requires modelling the marginal (or prior) distribution of random effects as a multivariate normal distribution. Simulations show that Method 1 performs well with Gaussian data but struggles with skewed continuous distributions, whereas Method 2 consistently performs well across various distributions, including normal, gamma, negative binomial, and Tweedie, with flexible link functions. A case study demonstrates the differences in model selection for real-world data between the conventional AIC and the conditional AIC. Based on our findings, we recommend Method 2 as a distributionally robust cAI criterion for model selection in mixed-effects models.
Authors: Nan Zheng, Noel G. Cadigan, James T. Thorson
Language: English
Subfield: Statistics and Probability
Field: Mathematics
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4404652900