Culling optimism: Circulating neoliberal affects in entrepreneurial animal disease policy
Year: 2024
Type: article
Abstract: • Animal disease eradication is conceptualised as cruel optimism. • Policy mobilities circulate neoliberal affects to promote logics of ownership. • Lived experience of ownership results in disillusion and mental exhaustion. • Policy mobilities serve to hide affectual realities of neoliberalism. • ‘Detached attachment’ reflects a continued but problematic relation to eradication. Using Berlant’s concept of cruel optimism, this paper explores how animal disease eradication can represent an unimaginable fantasy, the pursuit of which is an obstacle to farmers’ emotional and financial prosperity. The paper shows how atmospheres of optimism surrounding disease eradication are constructed and linked to policy mobilities. These apparent trans -national circulations of neoliberal logics of ‘ownership’ provide policy legitimacy at times of crisis, but also disguise the emotional experiences of neoliberal policy lives and serve political interests by marginalising alternatives to the allure of eradication. The paper bases these arguments within an analysis of the development of animal disease policy in England since 1997, and recent interviews and workshops exploring future policy options for disease control with farmers and other stakeholders. Following the development of bovine Tuberculosis policy, the paper shows how the transnational mobility of neoliberal policies promoting farmer ownership were used to legitimise farmer- owned culling companies to control infected wildlife. In describing how these policies unravelled through emotional burnout and disillusion amongst farmers, the paper describes the difficulties of detachment from a relation of cruel optimism, either marked by tragedy and trauma, or an incompleteness defined as ‘attached detachment’. In conclusion, the paper calls for further attention to other rural and agricultural fantasies to shed further light on the inequities of neoliberal life and need for just transitions.
Source: Geoforum
Language: English
Subfield: Agronomy and Crop Science
Domain: Life Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $3,620
Awards: G1093826604, G2039264503, G2859792602, Decision-making research into farmers’ cattle purchasing behaviour, investigating the current role of TB risk assessment in purchase decisions and appraising future ways to increase the importance of such risk assessment, G6201386131, G7222171459, G841499813, Social research project to understand farmer current/ future attitudes to cattle and badger TB vaccination in Britain
OpenAlex ID: W4404670983