Work

David Rodriguez . The View from Above in American Literature: Aerial Description, the Imaginary and the Form of Environment

Year: 2025
Type: book-review
Abstract: Towards the end of The View from Above in American Literature, David Rodriguez suggests that nature is always already mediated and represented. He draws from spatial theorist Gaston Bachelard’s idea of still waters, in which Bachelard suggests that humans and nature share a ‘will to contemplate’ (p. 178): the still pool has already seen and reflected the natural world back to the viewer, so the human figure can only contemplate nature as a reflexive form, after nature has done its representational work. The ‘eye of nature’ undergirds not only the earth’s watery topographies but its aerial atmospheres, and the way humans see and describe the environment from up above. Understanding the perception of the environment in this way—as in some senses co-constituted by humans and nature—has resulted in a refreshing ecocritical study of the aerial view. Scholarship on the aerial view rarely departs from the anthropocentric, focusing instead on the perspective as one of imperial power and surveillance, or as one of technological mediation and control—often, both at the same time. It also focuses overwhelmingly on visual and cultural studies, in fields like urban planning, geography, and film and photography studies, and features far less in literary criticism. This book contributes to ongoing revisionist studies which explore more pluralized and heterogeneous analyses of the aerial view. Rodriguez departs from Mary Louise Pratt’s literary study of the imperial gaze from above in Imperial Eyes (1992), as well as from a swath of work in visual culture on the aerial perspective as a technologically enabled ‘God’s-eye view’. In doing so, he makes a compelling case for unshackling studies of the aerial view from surveillant and techno-determinist approaches.
Author: Beryl Pong
Language: English
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W4408591763
Cites:
Cited by:
Related to: 8