Work

Editorial: Exploring the molecular mechanisms that regulate macrophage polarization

Year: 2025
Type: editorial
Abstract: Macrophages are ubiquitous innate immune cells that reside in almost every organ in the body. This family of phagocytes, represented by a variety of different subtypes, provide tissuespecific functions as diverse as the maintenance of surfactant homeostasis performed by alveolar macrophages of the lung (1) or the synaptic pruning carried out by the brain's microglial cells (2). However, these cells are united by a common role in host defense, providing a rapid response to microbial invaders and/or tissue damage. As part of this function, macrophages adopt activation states, also termed polarization, during different phases of an infection, cycling between the resting (M0) state in the absence of infection to a highly proinflammatory and antimicrobial state on exposure to microbial ligands or inflammatory cytokines referred to as M1. In contrast to this classical inflammatory activation, alternative macrophage activation states are referred to as M2, which can drive the resolution of inflammation and tissue repair, among other functions (3). This M1/M2 paradigm is not without its detractors. Several alternative models and naming systems were proposed over the years, and with good reason (4)(5)(6)(7)(8). At least 3 distinct Editorial: Exploring the Molecular Mechanisms that Regulate Macrophage Polarization types of M2 activation were proposed using idealized in vitro condition systems (9), and these systems cannot fully capture the complexity of these phenotypic shifts, which are a composite of multiple stimuli in specific tissue microenvironments overlaid with their temporal fluctuations. Furthermore, the M1/M2 system could be inappropriate for describing the behaviors of certain macrophage subtypes. For example, alveolar macrophages don't express or show minimal expression of many of the canonical M1 markers (10,11) and, due to their plasticity, often display intermediate M1/M2 phenotypes (12). For all its flaws, the M1/M2 system persists as a utilitarian shorthand that remains helpful when describing the pro-and anti-inflammatory extremes of the polarization continuum and the shifts of macrophage populations towards these extremes as parts of specific disease processes (13)(14)(15).Given the broad transcriptional reprogramming necessary for macrophages to transition from one polarization state to another, which is generally accepted to involve the altered expression of over 1,000 genes (16), significant attention has been focused on the core transcriptional regulators responsible for its control. The M1 state, as induced by interferongamma (IFNγ) and microbial ligands signaling via toll-like receptors, is largely controlled by STAT1 (17,18), IRF1 (19,20), and NF-κB (21), whereas the M2 state, as induced by interleukin (IL)-4, IL-10, and IL-13, is controlled mainly by STAT3, 6 (22), and PPARγ (23). These circuits are not separate but linked by a range of feedback loops and cross-inhibitory mechanisms that generally provide coherent shifts from one state to the other. Overlayed onto this are the activities of other transcription factors, including c-Myc (24), KLF4 (25), p53 (26), and HIF1 (27), which are better known for regulating other cellular processes, including cell proliferation, apoptosis, and the response to hypoxia, but still make significant contributions to the regulation of either or both the M1 and M2 state.In this Research Topic, which contains 6 (Mini) Reviews and Original Research Articles, we explore some of the lesser-known and often surprising contributors to macrophage polarization. These include extrinsic factors of the macrophage microenvironment, such as the biomechanical properties of the extracellular matrix and non-cytokine signaling agents, as well as intrinsic factors ranging from transcriptional co-regulators that modulate the activity of core M1 and M2 transcription factors to long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs) and microRNAs (miRNAs) that influence the process at a post-transcriptional level.In the first set of articles, which explores the role of the tissue microenvironment on macrophage polarization, Joshi et al. provide an Original Research article on how changes in tissue compliance or stiffness and integrin signaling contribute to this process. This work was motivated by the observation that mechanical properties differ markedly between tissues, with stiffness generally increasing in the disease state (e.g., infection, cancer, and fibrosis), which has the potential to impact macrophage phenotype through mechanotransduction. This was explored using an in vitro model system employing bone marrow-derived macrophages incubated on collagen-coated gels of varying stiffness and parallel experiments using leukadherin-1 (LA1), a CD11b agonist, used to activate integrin-mediated mechanical signaling independent of substrate. Here, the authors showed that softer substrates favor a macrophage host-defense phenotype. They also found that LA1 attenuates pro-inflammatory signaling by inhibiting Editorial: Exploring the Molecular Mechanisms that Regulate Macrophage Polarization NLRP3 activation. Given that a recent clinical trial using LA1 was halted as the drug was found to have no benefit to cancer patients, this work raises the prospect that LA1 could be repurposed as an immunomodulatory drug to treat select inflammatory disorders.The next Original Research article featured in our topic highlights a novel interaction of macrophages with a specific microbial component. In this rigorous study with mouse bone marrow-derived, peritoneal, and tumor-associated macrophages (TAMs), Zhang et al. demonstrated the effect of Escherichia coli adhesion portion of type I fimbriae (FimH), driving macrophage polarization status. The FimH, via a TLR4-mediated mechanism, did not only M1polarize resting macrophages but also M1-reprogramed the M2-macrophages induced by IL-4 and IL-13 cytokines or a tumor microenvironment. These properties of FimH were next validated in human macrophages and were shown to have therapeutic relevance. FimH could enhance anticancer immunity in C57BL/6 mice implanted with B16F10 melanoma treated with anti-PD-L1 antibody. These therapeutic effects were linked to the induction of M1 polarization in TAMs, a property that could be explored clinically as a future adjunct therapy to PD-L1 antibody treatment of tumors. Two review articles published in our topic focus on the lesser-known effects of growth factors and their receptors on macrophage polarization status. The first article by Shen et al.reviews fibroblast growth factor (FGF) signaling in macrophage polarization. The authors discuss the importance of the FGF/FGF receptor (FGFR) axis during homeostasis and disease processes. FGFs have diverse regulatory functions for physiological processes, promoting the growth and development of bones and organs. However, they also contribute to the development of diseases, including cancer and metastasis, inflammatory processes, and metabolic disorders.The relationship between macrophages and various FGFs is complex. For example, FGF1 and 2 promote M1-type activation, while FGF20 was reported to inhibit these pathways. In contrast, low molecular weight variants of FGF2 and FGF7 are either directly or indirectly linked to promoting M2 pathways. Likewise, the M1/M2 macrophage polarization cues trigger different subsets of FGFR expression by macrophages and the production of specific FGFs such as FGF23. Since both FGFs and macrophages are involved in the progression of tumors, autoimmune, and degenerative disorders, these interactions need to be further examined in their specific biological contexts.In the second review, Kannan and Rutkowski discuss the effects of vascular endothelial growth factor receptor-3 (VEGFR-3), which is highly expressed in lymphatic endothelial cells. However, monocyte-derived cells also express VEGFR-3 in specific organs like the lung and the gut, but also in tumors or other chronic disorders. For instance, VEGFR-3-expressing macrophages are protected from undesirable activation of pyroptosis pathways in the context of microbial infection, which results in better clearance and lesser inflammatory collateral damage of the infected tissues. However, the effects of VGFR-3 signaling on macrophage polarization appear to be contextual, especially during chronic diseases.Finally, a set of articles in our Research Topic concerns intrinsic modulators of the polarization transcriptional program. Here, we feature a mini-review by Wiggins et al., in which acid/aspartic acid-rich carboxy-terminal domain (CITED) family of transcriptional co-regulators.Here, they bring together recent literature to make the case that CITED1 and 2 function as general controllers of the M1 transcriptional program by regulating access to CBP/p300. This histone acetyltransferase can be considered a convergence point for signaling pathways regulating M1-associated gene expression as STAT, IRF, NF-κB, and HIF1 proteins utilize it as a coactivator. Here, CITED2 operates as a co-repressor, directly competing with these transcription factors for binding to a common interaction surface in CBP/p300, thereby attenuating pro-inflammatory gene expression. Conversely, CITED1 appears to enhance the expression of select pro-inflammatory genes, although the precise mechanisms for this remain enigmatic.The intrinsic regulation of macrophage status is exemplified by the unique function of a nucleic acids regulator, a lncRNA identified in macrophages of metastatic cancer, which is described in an Original Research article from Ahmad et al.. Here the authors explore the role of metastasis-associated lung adenocarcinoma 1 (MALAT1) lncRNA that is upregulated when monocytes are differentiated into M2 macrophages (28). This study found that MALAT1 functions as an antagonist of microRNAs from the miR-30 family, including miR-30b, which is known to support M2-associated gene expression. In this way, MALAT1 was found to bias macrophage polarization toward the M1 state by suppressing M2 gene expression.In closing, this collection of research and review articles describes recently discovered and lesser-known regulators of macrophage behavior and polarization. These are diverse in nature, operating by a variety of different mechanisms, including mechanotransduction, and transcriptional and post-transcriptional control, with some playing important roles in tumor macrophage behavior, leading to cancer suppression or promotion, while others are involved in the response to infection and acute tissue injury or play roles in autoimmune or chronic inflammatory diseases. The number of genes and pathways found to be involved in the macrophage polarization process continues to grow, further increasing the number of defined or hypothetical interactions in these regulatory networks. The apparent complexity of this speaks to the incredible sophistication of macrophage polarization and the need for its tight regulation. Our topic highlights just a small number of these regulatory mechanisms, and future studies will build on these, helping us better understand their contributions to health and disease.DEN and MAO wrote the manuscript. Both authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Language: English
Subfield: Immunology
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,801
OpenAlex ID: W4409510206
Cites: 28
Cited by: 1
Related to: 10