A Comparative Analysis of the Usability of Consumer Graphics Cards for Deep Learning in the Aspects of Inland Navigational Signs Detection for Vision Systems
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: Consumer-grade graphics processing units (GPUs) offer a potentially affordable and energy-efficient alternative to enterprise-class hardware for real-time image processing tasks, but systematic multi-criteria analyses of their suitability remain rare. This article fills that gap by evaluating the performance, power consumption, and cost-effectiveness of GPUs from three leading vendors, AMD, Intel, and Nvidia, in an inland water transport (ITW) context. The main objective is to assess the feasibility of using consumer GPUs for deep learning tasks involving navigational sign detection, a critical component for ensuring safe and efficient inland transportation. The evaluation includes the use of image datasets of inland water transport signs processed by widely used detector and classifier models such as YOLO (you only look once), ResNet (residual neural network l), and MobileNet. To achieve this, we propose a multi-criteria framework based on a weighted scoring method (WSM), covering 21 different characteristics such as compatibility, resting power, energy efficiency in learning and inference, and the financial threshold for technology adoption. The results confirm that consumer-grade GPUs can deliver competitive performance with lower initial costs and lower power consumption. The findings underscore the enduring value of our analysis, as its framework can be adapted for ongoing comparisons of evolving GPU technologies using the proposed methodology.
Source: Applied Sciences
DOI: 10.3390/app15095142
Authors: Pawel Adamski, Jacek Lubczonek
Institution: Maritime University of Szczecin
Language: English
Subfield: Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
Field: Computer Science
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $2,896
Funder: Uniwersytet Szczeciński
OpenAlex ID: W4410127314