Comparative Evaluation of Large Language and Multimodal Models in Detecting Spinal Stabilization Systems on X-Ray Images
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: Background/Objectives: Open-source AI models are increasingly applied in medical imaging, yet their effectiveness in detecting and classifying spinal stabilization systems remains underexplored. This study compares ChatGPT-4o (a large language model) and BiomedCLIP (a multimodal model) in their analysis of posturographic X-ray images (AP projection) to assess their accuracy in identifying the presence, type (growing vs. non-growing), and specific system (MCGR vs. PSF). Methods: A dataset of 270 X-ray images (93 without stabilization, 80 with MCGR, and 97 with PSF) was analyzed manually by neurosurgeons and evaluated using a three-stage AI-based questioning approach. Performance was assessed via classification accuracy, Gwet’s Agreement Coefficient (AC1) for inter-rater reliability, and a two-tailed z-test for statistical significance (p < 0.05). Results: The results indicate that GPT-4o demonstrates high accuracy in detecting spinal stabilization systems, achieving near-perfect recognition (97–100%) for the presence or absence of stabilization. However, its consistency is reduced when distinguishing complex growing-rod (MCGR) configurations, with agreement scores dropping significantly (AC1 = 0.32–0.50). In contrast, BiomedCLIP displays greater response consistency (AC1 = 1.00) but struggles with detailed classification, particularly in recognizing PSF (11% accuracy) and MCGR (4.16% accuracy). Sensitivity analysis revealed GPT-4o’s superior stability in hierarchical classification tasks, while BiomedCLIP excelled in binary detection but showed performance deterioration as the classification complexity increased. Conclusions: These findings highlight GPT-4o’s robustness in clinical AI-assisted diagnostics, particularly for detailed differentiation of spinal stabilization systems, whereas BiomedCLIP’s precision may require further optimization to enhance its applicability in complex radiographic evaluations.
Source: Journal of Clinical Medicine
DOI: 10.3390/jcm14103282
Language: English
Subfield: Health Informatics
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: gold
Estimated APC paid: $3,137
OpenAlex ID: W4410210733