Work

Assessing the effectiveness of travel control measures in preventing imported COVID-19 cases reveals the critical role of travel volume

Year: 2025

Type: article

Abstract: BACKGROUND: Although travel control measures have played a key role in mitigating COVID-19 spread in certain regions, few empirical observational studies have specifically quantified their effectiveness in preventing the importation of infectious cases into communities. In Hong Kong, layered policies (e.g., mandatory quarantine, staggered testing protocols, and phased travel volume restriction) provided a natural experiment to disentangle these components. Our study evaluates the contributions of each measure to preventing imported infectious cases releasing to community. METHODS: We retrospectively assessed these measures' effectiveness in Hong Kong, utilizing data from eight countries during 2020-2021. Data on imported COVID-19 cases, including departure origins and time from arrival to report, was compiled. To estimate the SARS-CoV-2 prevalence among inbound travelers, we used a Bayesian framework that accounted for the disease history and testing sensitivity and fitted to cases detected on arrival and travel volumes. We compared the number of prevented infections under the implemented measures to a scenario where no measures were taken. We also conducted counterfactual analysis to examine the independent and marginal effects of individual measures. RESULTS: Stringent travel measures prevented 9821 (9065 - 10,564) importations from entering Hong Kong. Travel volume reductions had the greatest impact (93.0 % reduction, 95 % confidence interval, CI: 91.9 %-93.9 %), followed by mandatory quarantine (80.8 % reduction, 95 % CI: 75.7 % - 87.1 %). In-quarantine COVID-19 testing showed no substantial additional effectiveness in preventing infectious COVID-19 cases into community (81.8 % reduction, 95 % CI:74.8 %-87.1 %) beyond mandatory quarantine alone. CONCLUSIONS: Our findings demonstrate that while stringent post-arrival measures effectively reduced community transmission of imported COVID-19 cases, travel volume reduction played a critical and independent role in limiting viral importation, regardless of post-arrival interventions.

Source: Epidemics

DOI: 10.1016/j.epidem.2025.100837

Authors: Mingwei Li, Karen A. Grépin, Ru Zhang, Benjamin J. Cowling, Bingyi Yang

Institutions: Laboratory of Data Discovery for Health, University of Hong Kong

Language: English

Topic: COVID-19 epidemiological studies

Subfield: Modeling and Simulation

Field: Mathematics

Domain: Physical Sciences

SDG: Good health and well-being

Open Access status: gold

Estimated APC paid: $2,730