Work

Comparative Analysis of Perturbation Characteristics Between LBGM and ETKF Initial Perturbation Methods in Convection-Permitting Ensemble Forecasts

Year: 2025

Type: article

Abstract: This study investigates an extreme squall line event that occurred in northern Jiangxi Province, China on 30–31 March 2024. Based on the WRF model, convection-permitting ensemble forecast experiments were conducted using two distinct initial perturbation approaches, namely, the Local Breeding of Growing Modes (LBGM) and the Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter (ETKF), to compare their perturbation structures, spatiotemporal evolution, and precipitation forecasting capabilities. The experiments demonstrated the following: (1) The LBGM method significantly improved the root mean square error (RMSE) of mid-upper tropospheric variables, particularly demonstrating superior performance in low-level temperature field forecasts, but the overall ensemble spread of the system was consistently smaller than that of ETKF. (2) The evolution of dynamical spread within the squall line system confirmed that ETKF generated greater spread growth in low-level wind fields, while LBGM exhibited better spatiotemporal alignment between mid-upper tropospheric wind field spread and the synoptic system evolution. (3) Vertical profiles of total moist energy revealed that ETKF initially exhibited higher total moist energy than LBGM. Both methods showed increasing total moist energy with forecast lead time, displaying a bimodal structure dominated by kinetic energy in upper layers (300–100 hPa) and balanced kinetic energy and moist physics terms in lower layers (1000–700 hPa), with ETKF demonstrating larger growth rates. (4) Kinetic energy spectrum analysis indicated that ETKF exhibited significantly higher perturbation energy than LBGM in the 100–1000 km mesoscale range and superior small- to medium-scale perturbation characterization at the 6–60 km scales initially. Precipitation and radar echo verification showed that ETKF effectively corrected positional biases in precipitation forecasts, while LBGM more accurately reproduced the bow-shaped echo structure near Nanchang due to its precise simulation of leading-edge vertical updrafts and rear-sector low pseudo-equivalent potential temperature regions.

Source: Atmosphere

DOI: 10.3390/atmos16060744

Authors: Jiajun Li, Chaohui Chen, Xiong Chen, Hongrang He, Yongqiang Jiang, Yanzhen Kang

Institution: National University of Defense Technology

Language: English

Topic: Meteorological Phenomena and Simulations

Subfield: Atmospheric Science

Field: Earth and Planetary Sciences

Domain: Physical Sciences

SDG: Climate action

Open Access status: gold

Estimated APC paid: $2,896