Work

HumanEvo: An Evolution-Aware Benchmark for More Realistic Evaluation of Repository-Level Code Generation

Year: 2025

Type: conference-paper

Abstract: To evaluate the repository-level code generation capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) in complex real-world software development scenarios, many evaluation methods have been developed. These methods typically leverage contextual code from the latest version of a project to assist LLMs in accurately generating the desired function. However, such evaluation methods fail to consider the dynamic evolution of software projects over time, which we refer to as evolution-ignored settings. This in turn results in inaccurate evaluation of LLMs' performance. In this paper, we conduct an empirical study to deeply understand LLMs' code generation performance within settings that reflect the evolution nature of software development. To achieve this, we first construct an evolution-aware repository-level code generation dataset, namely HumanEvo, equipped with an automated execution-based evaluation tool. Second, we manually categorize HumanEvo according to dependency levels to more comprehensively analyze the model's performance in generating functions with different dependency levels. Third, we conduct extensive experiments on HumanEvo with seven representative and diverse LLMs to verify the effectiveness of the proposed benchmark. We obtain several important findings through our experimental study. For example, we find that previous evolution-ignored evaluation methods result in inflated performance of LLMs, with performance overestimations ranging from 10.0% to 61.1% under different context acquisition methods, compared to the evolution-aware evaluation approach. Based on the findings, we give actionable suggestions for more realistic evaluation of LLMs on code generation. We also build a shared evolution-aware code generation toolbox to facilitate future research. The replication package including source code and datasets is anonymously available at https://github.Com/DeepSoftwareAnalytics/HumanEvo.

Source: IEEE/ACM International Conference on Software Engineering (ICSE)

DOI: 10.1109/icse55347.2025.00228