Trainer Feedback with C Mac Videolaryngoscope Screen Visible Only to Trainer does not Decrease Time to Endotracheal Intubation Compared to Conventional Laryngoscopy when Performed by Novice Anaesthesiologist Trainee: A Randomized Controlled Pilot Trial
Year: 2025
Type: article
Study designs: Randomized Controlled Trial, Clinical Trial
Abstract: Introduction: A shared view of the glottis to both the trainer and the novice anaesthesia trainee (NAT) appearsideal for teaching endotracheal intubation (ETI) with regards to decreased time to intubation, trainee-trainercomfort and lesser patient morbidity. However, this is not possible in direct laryngoscopy. Video laryngoscope(VL) may provide the solution. The present study hypothesised that the time to ETI would be lesser when a NATperforms ETI with a VL with screen of VL visible only to the trainer due to real-time feedback.Methods: First-semester anaesthesiology residents, with no previous ETI exposure were recruited and randomizedto two groups after teaching about ETI using a manual and video. Group A: ETI with DL with trainer verbalfeedback; Group B: ETI with VL with trainer verbal feedback, VL screen visible only to the trainer. The primaryoutcome was time to ETI. Secondary outcomes were success rate, teeth trauma/clicks by the laryngoscope,mucosal bleed, incidence of bougie use, trainee’s perception of difficulty and oesophageal intubations.Results: A total of 190 intubations were performed, 95 in each group. The mean time taken from insertion oflaryngoscope blade to completion of ETI was not statistically significant (01:07 mins in group A vs 1:00 min ingroup B; P=0.1). Second attempts were significantly more in Group B (P=0.002). None of the other secondaryoutcomes reached statistical significance.Conclusion: In NAT, trainer feedback via VL does not result in lesser time to intubation compared to conventionallaryngoscopy probably because of lack of optimal skill and performance anxiety. Second attempts for ETI weresignificantly more in the former group because of trainer reassurance of visibility of attempt on VL screen.
DOI: 10.55487/f1gf3q90
Authors: Sowmiya Krishnamoorthy, Jyotsna Punj, Vanlal Darlong, Ravinder Kumar Pandey, Renu Sinha, Souvik Maitra
Institution: All India Institute of Medical Sciences
Language: English
Subfield: Anesthesiology and Pain Medicine
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: diamond
OpenAlex ID: W4413011347