The Value to False Belief in Plato’s Republic
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: This paper examines the intricate role of false beliefs in Plato’s Republic, particularly on the philosophical paradox presented by the “spirit of truthfulness” and the falsehoods and fictions that Plato incorporates into his educational system. Although Plato is often criticized for endorsing deception among political rulers, this study argues that he also emphasizes the importance of certain fictions in the pursuit of truth and social harmony. Beginning with an analysis of the cave allegory, the paper attempts to explain the epistemic obligations of philosopher-kings, to rule with accessible narratives, even if they involve falsehood. Furthermore, the paper explores how the noble lie naturalizes the education of the guardians, thereby reinforcing the legitimacy of the ruling class. Reciting diverse scholarly perspectives, it is underscored the ethical ramifications of using falsehoods in governance and their potential utility in fostering societal stability. Ultimately, the paper concludes that Plato’s approach to falsehood provides foundational grounds for ruling towards common good, while also evoking discussions complexities of truth, ethical governance, and political authority.
DOI: 10.61784/jrep3009
Author: RuoNan Liu
Language: English
Subfield: Philosophy
Field: Arts and Humanities
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
OpenAlex ID: W4413805248