Assessing the performance of large language model Artificial Intelligence in thyroid cancer multidisciplinary team (MDT) decision-making
Year: 2025
Type: article
Abstract: Background Large language models (LLMs) have potential in augmenting clinical decision-making. The performance of three leading LLMs (ChatGPT, MetaAI, and DeepSeek) was evaluated in thyroid cancer MDT decision-making. Method Forty clinical cases (20 simulated/20 genuine), median age 45 (25–74), 26F, were discussed in a regional thyroid cancer MDT to provide the reference decisions. Cases were then blind-assessed by three LLMs that had been trained on contemporary guidelines, using uniform prompts. LLM outcomes were compared with reference decisions via a 4-point concordance score. Thematic analysis was performed. Results ChatGPT demonstrated the highest overall concordance score, 97/120 (36 cases concordant/near-concordant), DeepSeek scored 93/120 (33 concordant/near-concordant) and MetaAI performed least well 87/120. Despite identical guideline references, LLMs offered differing interpretation and application. ChatGPT offered the greatest nuance, with outputs that closely mirrored MDT phrasing and reasoning, especially around complex/borderline cases. ChatGPT and DeepSeek explicitly acknowledged patient choice, but ChatGPT more consistently contextualised it within guideline-compliant treatment options. MetaAI demonstrated more variability, with several examples of overtreatment or misalignment with current clinical practice. None of the LLMs recommended more recent treatment options for poorly-differentiated/anaplastic disease such as neoadjuvant or combination chemotherapy. Conclusion LLMs showed good concordance with clinical MDT decisions, even in complex real-world cases. However, despite receiving the same prompts there were differences in reasoning. ChatGPT’s nuanced, context-aware outputs appear most promising as a decision-support tool. Last, because LLMs lack intrinsic capability for continual learning at present, they have clear limitations, for example in keeping pace with some areas of advancing clinical practice.
Source: British journal of surgery
Authors: A W White, R E Egan, D S C Scott-Coombes, N P Patel, M S Stechman
Institutions: Morriston Hospital, University Hospital of Wales
Language: English
Subfield: Health Informatics
Field: Medicine
Domain: Health Sciences
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W4417236780