Year: 2026
Type: article
Abstract: Design Reviews (DRs) function as formal governance checkpoints within the product development process where cross-functional stakeholders evaluate design proposals against product requirements to determine their readiness for progression. As design teams become increasingly global, they rely heavily on remote and digital workflows to conduct DRs. While research explores the implementation of new tools to enhance collaboration in DRs, studies often focus on technical feasibility or interaction effects in isolated settings rather than on how these technologies can be embedded in actual industrial processes. In this study, we examine the use of advanced collaboration tools, defined here as digital systems that provide shared spatial environments, in-scene deictic referencing, and independent navigation. Currently, organizations lack actionable guidance on integrating these tools into their DR processes. Thus, this paper develops an evidence-informed set of procedural guidelines for planning, conducting, and documenting DRs using advanced collaboration tools. Working with two automotive companies, we conducted a multi-phase study where two real industrial cases (one per company) were reconstructed to facilitate collaborative workshops aimed at mapping technological capabilities to procedural rules. The analysis draws on established accounts of grounding, workspace awareness, distributed cognition, and organizational routines to interpret the coordination breakdowns observed and the routines that address them. By analyzing verbal data and interaction logs, we developed a set of guidelines grounded in the specific coordination problems identified by practitioners and the technological capabilities required to resolve them. The resulting guidelines identify five domains, including pre-read and preparation, attention management, documentation and traceability, integration and handoff, and modality and role distribution. The guidelines provide a transferable structure for organizations to transform advanced collaboration tools from isolated visualizers into reliable, managed elements of the DRs workflow.
Source: Research in Engineering Design
Language: English
Subfield: Mechanical Engineering
Field: Engineering
Domain: Physical Sciences
Open Access status: hybrid
Estimated APC paid: $4,090
Funder: Högskolan i Skövde
OpenAlex ID: W4417489630
