Work

Feminism, co-optation and the problems of amnesia: a response to Nancy Fraser

Year: 2013
Type: article
Abstract: Understanding the past and present possibilities of linking feminist and anti-capitalist politics is critical to understanding the conditions under which subordination comes to be challenged. In the wake of the totalizing effects of the recent crisis of capitalism, some intellectuals have shifted their gaze to the economy and are re-evaluating the rise and decline of left political movements, including feminism. Nancy Fraser’s ‘Feminism, Capitalism and the Cunning of History’ is perhaps one of the more clear, succinctly stated and possibly influential discussions of this connection, in part because of its appearance in New Left Review. Fraser’s ambitious excursion through the making and unmaking of feminist critique over the last forty years urges us to reclaim the best ideas of second-wave feminism, striving for ‘transformation in the direction of justice’. Her argument that feminism was ‘co-opted’ is gaining much broader currency; scholars are now repeating her argument that capitalism and feminism became ‘compatible bedfellows’ applying her ideas to other social movements. However, before we rush to a consensus, we need to look critically at her version of the feminist past, and her vision of a feminist future. Like Fraser, we see the imperative of rethinking feminist debates that have ignored labour issues and de-emphasized the structural and material, instead giving more attention to the intersections of class politics and feminist strategies for change. However, her reinterpretation of feminist history, in which a homogenized second-wave feminism inevitably becomes a compliant bedfellow, or worse, an apologist for global capitalism, largely through women’s claims for equality in the field of labour, needs to be challenged. If we are to understand the partial incorporation of some feminist ideas – liberal, cultural, postmodern – into capitalism, and the role they play in its legitimation, then we need to theorize those specific connections.
Language: English
Subfield: Gender Studies
Open Access status: bronze
OpenAlex ID: W55900174
FWCI: 5.272
Cites: 26
Cited by: 18
Related to: 10