Work

Autonomy and connection : identity, moral reasoning and coping among new mothers

Year: 1991
Type: article
Study design: Observational Study
Abstract: Women's sense of self develops through the interplay of autonomy (experienced through self definition and power) and connection with others (experienced as love, responsibility, and dependency).Changes in autonomy bring about a redefinition of terms in close relationships, and vicaversa.James Marcia's Identity Status model of ego identity and Carol Gilligan's care-based model of moral reasoning are partial and compatible descriptions of the development of the self in relation to others in young adulthood.In both models, persons at lower levels of development are seen as reactive to others and as having a diffuse sense of self definition.Those at a conventional level experience self and others through reciprocal roles prescribed by internalized authority figures.At the highest levels of development, persons undergo periods of self-exploration, and define themselves and their relationships in unique terms.An integrative model of women's ego development is needed to account for the reciprocal nature of autonomy and connection in women's lives.In the context of new motherhood, where role expectations are ambiguous and conflicting, a woman's integration of autonomy and connection should guide the degree to which she reacts according to the expectations of others (reactive coping) vs. to her own expectations and needs (role redefinition).It was hypothesized that women's scores on Identity Status, Care-based Moral Reasoning and coping strategy (reactive coping vs. role redefinition) would be associated with one another, since each was seen as reflecting a single developmental process.Interviews and questionnaires from 79 mothers with first children ages 6-18 months were scored for Identity Status, Care-based Moral Reasoning and coping strategy.Identity was significantly associated with Moral Reasoning and marginally associated with caping strategy.Moral Reasoning was not associated with coping strategy.Women's ratings on Identity Status and Moral Reasoning were related to level of education, emplol-ment status and familyincome.An integrated model of women's development of the self in relation to others is described, using illustrative material from the interview.
Language: English
Field: Psychology
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W573742579
FWCI: 0.467
Cites: 61
Cited by: 2
Related to: 10