Year: 2014
Type: book-chapter
Abstract: Is Northern Ireland a ''Model''? James HughesElite discourses about the lessons to be drawn from the Northern Ireland conflict and the 1998 Belfast Agreement share many of the same concerns as those in academia concerned with designing fixes to violent conflict and postconflict reconciliation and reconstruction.A curious feature of the discourse about Northern Ireland being a ''model'' for conflict resolution is that it stresses process over outcome.There is much emphasis on ''dialogue'' while there is also much reticence about promoting the actual content of the agreements that brought the violent conflict to an end-the consociational institutional engineering-as a key element in the ''model.''There is also much reticence about structural features of the conflict and the challenges of reconciliation and reconstruction in a divided society.The major lesson that policy makers have drawn from this case is that even the most protracted conflicts can be ended, and ''dialogue'' with the extremes can pay dividends for peacemaking.It is a paradox of the peace agreement in Northern Ireland that the ethnic power reallocation under consociationalism has fostered interethnic elite accommodation and cooperation, while at least in the short term hardening the obstacles to a social transformation from divided society to a more integrated one.Criticisms of consociationalism tend to reflect a normative repulsion to the ethnification of politics entailed in its institutional features (invariably understood as a reification After Civil War : Division, Reconstruction, and Reconciliation in Contemporary Europe, edited by Bill Kissane,
Author: James Hughes
Language: English
Topic: Irish and British Studies
Subfield: Sociology and Political Science
Field: Social Sciences
Domain: Social Sciences
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W575617890
