Work

The legal and human rights basis of HIV positive undocumented African migrants’ access to healthcare services in the UK and US: a non-governmental organization based study

Year: 2011
Type: dissertation
Abstract: This thesis established the relationship between actual practices, law and\nhuman rights in HIV positive undocumented African migrants’ quest to gain\nhealth related services in the United Kingdom and the United States. The\nthesis establishes this through an examination of extant law and literature\nand an empirical exploration of actual practices. The empirical component of\nthe thesis is based methodologically upon the Grounded Theory Method.\nData was collected from various Non-Governmental Organizations within\neach of the respective countries.\nThe arguments and conclusions of the thesis hinge on the interaction\nbetween laws that facilitate or prevent access to health services under\nhumanitarian grounds in the respective nations. The major theoretical\nconcern identified in the study centers upon the moment at which the\nindividual migrant loses their legal status. In the case of the UK, this\ngenerally occurs after the application and appeal for asylum have failed. In\nthe US, the majority of persons experience this loss of legal status far earlier,\nsince few Africans enter the country incident to asylum applications. The\nresults of the thesis considerable inconsistencies in the implementation of\nlaw in the case of both countries, and establishes the governmental and nongovernmental\nfactors that influence the provision of such services. While\nservices continue to be available in life threatening circumstances, there is\ncurrently no legally mandated point prior to this that care is mandated. Thus,\nthe initially degradation of health in the case of people living with\nHIV/AIDS is inevitable.\nThe domestic laws of the UK and US are equivalent in that both guarantee\ncare only in cases where life is acutely threatened. The functional aspects of\nthe two systems are significantly different. In the case of the US, there are\nfew programs that offer government funded care to even legal citizens, thus\ncare for even legal migrants is difficult to obtain. The UK conversely is\ncharacterized by near universal access to general practitioners with patchy\naccess to consultants who provide HIV related care. In the cases of both\ncountries, there is a likelihood that an individual may receive HIV related\ncare and later be denied care resulting in the eventual deterioration of there\nhealth.\nThe thesis concludes that there is need for reconsideration of the current\napproach to law in both the UK and US, given existing international human\niv\nrights declarations. In the context of HIV/AIDS, this is particularly profound\ngiven the chronic nature of the disease, its amenability to treatment, and the\ninevitability of death in cases where treatment is withheld.
Source: Figshare
Author: James Whyte
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W581891161
Cites: 178
Cited by:
Related to: 10