Work

Negotiating the constitutional conundrum: Balancing cultural identity with principles of gender equality in post-colonial South Pacific societies

Year: 2006
Type: article
Abstract: One of the most significant challenges currently facing the island states of the southwest Pacific is that of dealing with the competing claims of customary norms and rules on the one hand and contemporary international human rights on the other. Some commentators have assumed these goals to be complementary, a stance which ignores the fundamentally different values involved. Nowhere is the conflict between customary law and human rights more relevantly illustrated than in the area of gender equality. This paper looks at a small sample of South Pacific cases highlighting this conflict and at the way in which the competing norms have been balanced by the courts. The paper considers the constitutional conundrum facing South Pacific nations with a constitutional mandate to preserve a unique cultural identity, which involves a conservative manifesto, whilst upholding human rights agendas developed in a very different context. The dichotomy linking tradition with subjugation and Westernization with freedom and equality is also brought into question.
Language: English
Subfield: Law
Open Access status: green
OpenAlex ID: W61152453
FWCI: 9.598
Cites:
Cited by: 13
Related to: 9